Looking for restaurants? Our top picks are Horn's Hook Tavern, Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet and Anita La Mamma del Gelato, ranked by diner ratings. The full list below updates as menus change.
Discover the top-rated dining experiences
Experience the best italian restaurants in Carnegie Hill. From authentic flavors to modern interpretations, discover top-rated italian dining.
Carnegie Hill's Premier Italian Destinations
Nestled within the elegant streets of Carnegie Hill, this curated selection of restaurants highlights the rich culinary traditions of Italy alongside classic American fare. Diners can explore a diverse range of experiences, from the sophisticated plates at Sandro's and Al Vaporetto to the casual, authentic slices at Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet. Whether you are seeking a hearty meal at Horn's Hook Tavern or a refreshing scoop from Anita La Mamma del Gelato, these local favorites offer the perfect setting for any occasion.
30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Top Rated Italian Food
- Horn's Hook Tavern · rated 5/5: American.
- Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet · rated 5/5: Italian.
- Anita La Mamma del Gelato · rated 5/5: Italian.
- Supreme Eats Pizza & Pasta Corp · rated 4.9/5: Italian.
- Sandro's · rated 4.8/5: Italian.
- L'Osteria · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- parma Nuova · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Sandro's Restaurant · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Enzo Bruni La Pizza Gourmet · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Al Vaporetto · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Trattoria L'incontro · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Masseria East · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th) · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- La Pecora Bianca UES · rated 4.7/5: Italian.
- Lex Restaurant · rated 4.6/5: Italian.
- Luna Rossa · rated 4.6/5: Italian.
- Village Square Pizza - Upper East Side · rated 4.6/5: Italian.
- BM Deli Grocery · rated 4.6/5: American.
- Arturo's · rated 4.6/5: Italian.
- Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant · rated 4.6/5: Italian.
- Siena Cafe · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Don Filippo · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Antonucci Cafe · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Sfoglia · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Il Carino · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Due · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- La Voglia NYC · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- G&J's Pizzeria · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- IL Carino Restaurant · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
- Osteria Nando · rated 4.5/5: Italian.
How this list is built
Chefi analyzes each restaurant’s menu and tags every dish’s dietary suitability with an ingredient-based engine. Restaurants with at least three matching dishes on their current menu rank first, ordered by diner ratings, with the number of matching dishes breaking ties; owner-verified restaurants are highlighted at the top. Lists refresh as menus and ratings change.
