Best Italian Restaurants in Harlem | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Harlem | Top Rated Italian Food

• Vinateria — Italian · rated 5/5: This stylish Harlem corner sanctuary invites guests into a sun-drenched space where black-and-white tiled floors and a sleek zinc bar set the stage for a soulful Mediterranean journey. The air hums with the energy of a neighborhood favorite as vibrant plates of seasonal Italian and Spanish-inspired fare emerge from the kitchen, perfectly complemented by a thoughtfully curated wine program that celebrates small-batch producers. It is a place where the elegance of a downtown bistro meets the heartfelt warmth of a local haunt, making every meal feel like a celebratory escape.
• Nokka LLC — American · rated 5/5: Nokka LLC, located at 2319 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, is a delightful Italian restaurant known for its homemade dishes crafted with top-quality ingredients. With options for dine-in, takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup, it's a perfect spot for lunch or dinner with the family. Praised for its exceptional jerk wings and burgers, Nokka LLC is highly rated by its patrons and offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
• Pastitalia — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Pastitalia, nestled in Harlem, is a charming Italian eatery known for its fresh pasta, aromatic coffee, and delectable pastries. From hearty breakfast options to satisfying lunches and delightful desserts, the menu features authentic Italian recipes with popular dishes like pesto bucatini and berry tart. With a cozy ambiance, friendly staff, a kids' menu, and ample outdoor seating, Pastitalia offers a true taste of Italy right in New York City.
• Enoteca Harlem — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in Central Harlem, Enoteca Harlem offers a delightful blend of Spanish and Chilean cuisines with cozy, romantic vibes perfect for brunch, dinner, or late-night. Guests rave about the knowledgeable and welcoming staff, delectable dishes like paella and octopus, and an impressive selection of Chilean wines. With both indoor and patio seating, it’s an ideal spot to enjoy a wonderful meal and great company.
• Dado's Pizza and Taproom Harlem — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in Harlem, Dado's Pizza and Taproom offers a delightful experience with its New York-style pizzas, garlic knots, wings, and a selection of beer, wine, and cider. Whether you're dining in or taking out, the cozy atmosphere and friendly staff ensure an enjoyable visit. With a user rating of 4.7 and rave reviews from locals and visitors alike, it's a must-visit spot for pizza lovers! 🍕
• Sottocasa — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled on 227 Malcolm X Blvd in New York, Sottocasa offers a delightful array of Neapolitan-style pizzas, including gluten-free options, all served in a stylish and inviting setting. Perfect for family outings, it boasts both indoor and outdoor seating and serves wine, beer, and coffee to complement your meal. Rated 4.7 by over 1300 users, it's a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking authentic flavor.
• Sottocasa — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located at 298 Atlantic Ave in Brooklyn, Sottocasa is a welcoming neighborhood pizzeria that specializes in crafting thin-crust, wood-fired pizzas. With a rating of 4.6 from over 1,000 reviews, it's a hit with locals and visitors alike. Sottocasa offers a family-friendly vibe, outdoor seating, and an excellent selection of beer and wine. A great spot for both lunch and dinner, the restaurant also caters to takeout and delivery orders.
• Lido — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Lido captures the sun-drenched spirit of the Italian coast, welcoming guests into a breezy, light-filled space that hums with the effortless elegance of a Mediterranean summer. The air carries the intoxicating aroma of charred crusts and simmering pomodoro, as the kitchen turns out silken, hand-rolled pastas and vibrant seafood dishes that celebrate the simple, soulful beauty of seasonal ingredients. It is a place designed for lingering, where crisp glasses of wine and shared rustic plates invite diners to slow down and savor the timeless rhythm of la dolce vita.
• Vinateria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Vinateria serves as a chic neighborhood sanctuary where the sun-drenched warmth of a Mediterranean villa meets the polished energy of a modern bistro. The air hums with the clink of glasses and the aroma of garden-fresh herbs as guests savor silken, hand-rolled pastas and vibrant seasonal plates crafted with an artisanal touch. It is a place where time slows over a perfectly paired vintage, offering a sophisticated yet soulful escape into the heart of Italian hospitality.
• Babbalucci — Italian · rated 4.5/5: The flickering amber light of a wood-burning oven casts a warm glow over this spirited Harlem destination, where the air is perfumed with the scent of charred dough and slow-simmered sauces. Artisanal pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts share the table with bowls of silky, hand-rolled pasta, offering a soulful celebration of Italian craft that feels both effortlessly chic and deeply welcoming.
• Vinatería — Spanish · rated 4.5/5: Welcome to Vinatería, a chic and contemporary restaurant located on Frederick Douglass Blvd in New York. Renowned for its upscale Italian and Spanish-influenced cuisine, Vinatería pairs exquisite dishes with fine wine and cocktails. The inviting ambiance, coupled with exceptional service, makes it perfect for an intimate dinner or a family outing. With accessibility options, outdoor seating, and a delightful menu that includes vegetarian and children's options, Vinatería promises a fantastic dining experience.
• Fumo Harlem — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Discover Fumo Harlem, an Italian restaurant nestled at 1600 Amsterdam Ave, New York. Renowned for its late-night hours, Fumo offers a delightful array of pizza, pasta, and other traditional dishes. Rated 4.5 stars by 1637 patrons, it captivates with its vibrant ambiance, friendly service, and delicious menu, including gluten-free and dairy-free options. Enjoy free street parking, outdoor seating, and a selection of fine wines.
• The Corner Lounge — American · rated 4.5/5: Welcome to The Corner Lounge, a beloved spot in Harlem offering a delightful blend of American comfort food and Italian favorites. With a cozy ambiance, a full bar, and live music, it’s perfect for family dinners, sports nights, and relaxed brunches. Enjoy a diverse menu, including options for children, alongside a commendable 4.5-star rating from happy patrons. Visit us at 32 E 130th St, or call +1 917-409-0555 for reservations.
• Rosa Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located at 2210 Frederick Douglass Blvd, New York, Rosa Pizza offers a casual dining atmosphere with a delectable variety of pizzas for all taste preferences. Open daily with convenient takeout and delivery options, this family-friendly spot even serves wine to complement your meal. With a robust 4.4-star rating, Rosa Pizza is a beloved local favorite, perfect for enjoying a delicious slice in Harlem.
• Il Caffe Latte — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 189 Malcolm X Blvd, Il Caffe Latte offers a cozy, casual atmosphere to enjoy breakfast, lunch, and dinner with Italian influences. Known for its strong coffee and robust menu, this neighborhood gem serves delicious meals accompanied by beer and wine. With a 4.4-star rating and wheelchair-accessible facilities, Il Caffe Latte is perfect for a delightful dining experience.
• Lido Harlem Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in Central Harlem, Lido Harlem Restaurant offers an elegant Italian dining experience with a cozy, romantic ambiance. Particularly renowned for its brunch, this lively spot serves delectable dishes like the braised short rib hash, salmon benedict, and chicken sandwich. With a warm and commendable service, reservations for their popular bottomless mimosa brunch are recommended. A perfect location for both families and solo diners, this charming venue invites you to savor its delightful cuisine and enjoy its inviting outdoor seating.
• Pepo’s Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Hamilton Heights, Pepo's Pizza offers a cozy and informal atmosphere perfect for families and groups alike. Serving up delicious lunch, brunch, dinner, and late-night bites, the menu includes classic pizza, hearty comfort foods, vegetarian options, and halal selections. Popular dishes feature chicken tenders, garlic knots, and flavorful wings. With convenient takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup options, Pepo's Pizza ensures everyone can enjoy high-quality, affordable eats ($1-10) with ease. High chairs are available for little ones, making it a child-friendly destination. For more, visit us at 1522 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY.
• Uncle Tony's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Uncle Tony's on Amsterdam Avenue is a must-visit for New York-style pizza lovers. Boasting a variety of delicious pies, including vegetarian and vegan options, this local pizzeria is perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner. With friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere, it's great for families and groups. Enjoy takeout or delivery, paired with a selection of wine and beer. Rated an impressive 4.3, it's a delightful spot in the heart of NYC.
• Pizza 2 Go — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Nestled on E 125th St in New York, Pizza 2 Go offers delicious, budget-friendly pizza by the slice. With a solid 4.3-star rating from satisfied patrons, it’s a great spot for a quick bite, whether you're grabbing lunch or dinner. Open daily from 10:00 AM to 9:30 PM, they welcome both dine-in and takeout orders. Plus, they accept various payment options, making it convenient for everyone.
• Esayi Pizza & Deli — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Located at 2461 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, Esayi Pizza & Deli in New York offers an inviting space with a diverse menu featuring fresh pizza and deli options. Open daily from 6 AM to 2 AM, it caters to lunch, dinner, and coffee lovers. With a 4.3-star rating and friendly staff, it's perfect for families and accepts various payment methods, making it a convenient stop for all.
• Pizza Stop — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Pizza Stop is a delightful eatery located at 2166 Frederick Douglass Blvd in New York. Known for its amazing deep-dish pizzas and calzones, this family-friendly restaurant has garnered a commendable rating of 4.2 from 130 reviews. Open every day from 11:00 AM to 9:45 PM, Pizza Stop offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. With friendly staff and a wide array of delicious menu items, it’s a must-visit spot for pizza lovers. Website: [Pizza Stop](https://www.nycpizzastop.com/2166frederickdouglassblvdnewyorkny10026).
• Harlem Pizza Co. — Italian · rated 4.1/5: ♪ Experience Harlem Pizza Co. in Central Harlem, where casual meets comfort. Specializing in delicious brick-oven pies like pepperoni, margherita, and smoked shrooms, their menu also features salads, calzones, and shishito peppers, with mimosas and vegetarian options available. The cozy ambiance is perfect for families, offering quick service and a range of seating including outdoor options. With a 4.1 rating based on 270 reviews, it's a local favorite for lunch and dinner. Enjoy fast service and delightful pies starting at just $10. (135 W 116th St, NY) ♪
• Pizza Stop — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Welcome to Pizza Stop on Malcolm X Blvd, New York! This beloved pizzeria serves up delicious New York-style pies along with a variety of comfort foods like chicken alfredo, spaghetti, and buffalo wings, perfect for dine-in or takeout. With vegetarian options and an unpretentious setting great for kids and solo diners, it's a top choice for a casual, tasty meal. Enjoy a meal, typically ranging from $10-$20, and savor the flavors that make this spot a local favorite.
• Lavittas — Italian · rated 4.1/5: Located at 218 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, Lavittas is a charming Creole-inspired restaurant that dazzles with a relaxed atmosphere and delectable menu offerings. Open Thursday to Sunday, this spot boasts a 4.1-star rating, reflecting its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Accepting credit and debit cards, Lavittas invites you to savor delightful dishes like crawfish cakes and beignets. Enjoy the unique Creole vibe and welcoming service on your next culinary adventure.
• Il Caffe Latte — Italian · rated 4/5: Sunlight streams through the windows of this inviting neighborhood sanctuary, where the rich, nutty aroma of freshly pulled espresso mingles with the buttery scent of golden pastries. Guests linger over velvety lattes and artisanal light bites in a space defined by warm wood accents and a gentle, rhythmic hum that turns a simple coffee break into a soulful daily ritual.
• Fresh Hot Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: Fresh Hot Pizza, located at 17 W 125th St, New York, offers a delightful dining experience with an impressive 4-star rating. Known for its friendly service and great prices, it’s a fantastic spot for families and children. The restaurant is open daily with convenient hours, making it easy to enjoy their tasty pizzas anytime. They also offer takeout, delivery, and curbside pickup, and accept various payment methods. Visit [their website](http://www.freshhotpizzaorder.com/) or call (917) 261-2859 for more information.
• Pizza del valle — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Nestled at 3340 Broadway, in the heart of Manhattan, Pizza del Valle offers a delightful array of thin, crispy New York-style slices. Open daily from 10 AM to 10 PM, this welcoming spot prides itself on a clean, airy dining space and free street parking. Perfect for families and on-the-go diners, the restaurant provides both dine-in and take-out options, accepting various payment methods. Don't miss their $5 deal for two cheese slices and a drink!
• Mama Tina's Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3.8/5: Nestled in Central Harlem, Mama Tina's Pizzeria serves up beloved New York-style comfort food. This casual, family-friendly spot offers a variety of pizzas, sandwiches, salads, and calzones, with popular dishes like baked ziti, chicken parmesan, and garlic knots. Ideal for both solo diners and families, customers typically spend $10-20. Open daily for lunch and dinner, Mama Tina's is a local favorite for affordable, tasty eats.
• Empanadas Monumental — Spanish · rated 3.8/5: Located in the heart of Elizabeth, NJ, Empanadas Monumental serves up classic Dominican comfort food in a relaxed, casual setting. Popular dishes include empanadas, yaroa sandwiches, and pizza, alongside favorites like longaniza with tostones and club sandwiches with fries. Open late on weekends, this spot offers dine-in, takeout, and catering services, making it a versatile choice for any occasion.
• Mama's Fried Chicken — American · rated 3.5/5: Nestled at 2925 Frederick Douglass Blvd, Mama's Fried Chicken offers a delightful culinary experience with a focus on fresh and efficiently prepared meals. This family-friendly spot is open late, providing ample time to enjoy their varied menu, including popular choices like pizza and chicken. Conveniently accepting credit cards, Mama's Fried Chicken is a welcoming spot in New York for takeout and casual dining.