Best Italian Restaurants in Omaha | Top Rated Italian Food

29 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Omaha | Top Rated Italian Food

• Durham Cafe — American · rated 4/5: Sunlight dances across the tables of this inviting neighborhood gem, where the air is perfumed with the enticing aroma of spice-kissed vodka sauce and earthy, slow-stirred risotto. The kitchen artfully blends global inspirations, offering a vibrant landscape of flavors that range from the fiery crunch of chili-crisp pasta to the bright, garden-fresh zest of a seasonal tomato panzanella. Whether settling in for a nourishing Korean rice bowl or a leisurely brunch of avocado toast, guests find a warm sanctuary that celebrates bold, modern comfort food in every thoughtfully plated dish.
• Sips on 10th — Italian · rated 4/5: Sips on 10th pulses with a chic, high-energy charm, inviting guests into a sleek social hub where the comforting decadence of smoked gouda mac and cheese meets the light, golden crunch of tender calamari. The air buzzes with laughter and the rhythmic clinking of glasses as vibrant green tea shots and signature house pours flow freely, creating a spirited backdrop for an unforgettable night out in the heart of the city.
• The Good Life - at the Creek — American · rated 3/5: Perched by the water's edge, this vibrant gathering spot hums with the energy of a classic neighborhood hangout where the scent of bubbling house pizzas and searing burgers fills the air. Guests settle into the relaxed atmosphere to indulge in elevated comforts, from the gooey, golden richness of smoked gouda mac and cheese to the savory depth of a perfectly pressed prime melt. Whether sharing a basket of crispy, hand-cut wings or enjoying a leisurely meal overlooking the creek, every bite celebrates the simple joy of hearty, well-crafted favorites.
• Sam and Louie's Italian Restaurant & Pizza — Italian · rated 3/5: This vibrant neighborhood hub hums with the convivial energy of a classic New York pizzeria, where the irresistible aroma of bubbling mozzarella and garlic-infused crust drifts from the open kitchen. Guests gather around oversized hand-tossed pies and steaming plates of traditional pasta, savoring a dining experience that balances the satisfying crunch of a perfect crust with the comforting, soul-warming flavors of a family-run Italian kitchen.
• Orsi's Italian Bakery & Pizzeria — Italian · rated 3/5: Step into a timeless neighborhood landmark where the intoxicating aroma of toasted garlic and hearth-baked dough fills the air, drawing guests into a space steeped in Italian tradition. Golden, bubbling sheet pizzas emerge from the ovens with perfectly crisped edges, while piles of warm, buttery garlic bread serve as the soul-satisfying centerpiece of every communal meal. Whether grabbing a quick mini-pizza or sharing a sprawling half-sheet with the family, every bite captures the rustic charm and enduring heritage of a true artisan bakery.
• Mama's Pizza — Italian: Stepping into Mama's Pizza feels like a warm embrace, where the comforting aroma of hand-tossed dough and slow-simmered tomato sauce wafts from a bustling open kitchen. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven topped with molten mozzarella and vibrant herbs, inviting guests to linger over shared plates in a space defined by nostalgic charm. This neighborhood gem captures the soulful essence of a family kitchen, turning every meal into a celebration of simple, time-honored flavors and heartfelt hospitality.
• Pitch Pizzeria — Italian: This high-energy social hub pulses with the aroma of charred dough and bubbling cheese, drawing guests into a space where modern flair meets rustic comfort. The table fills quickly with vibrant plates of zesty Calabrese meatballs and sweet goat cheese peppadews, setting the stage for artisanal pizzas with perfectly blistered crusts and crisp, garden-fresh salads. It is a spirited neighborhood destination where every meal feels like a celebration of bold flavors and communal dining.
• Noli's Pizzeria — Italian: The air at Noli’s Pizzeria is heavy with the irresistible scent of buttery garlic knots and savory meatballs, drawing guests into a space that hums with the warmth of a spirited neighborhood gathering spot. Tables are laden with bubbling wheels of baked brie and steaming bowls of mussels, offering a sophisticated twist on the classic pizzeria experience that invites lingering over shared plates and crisp, vibrant salads. From the colorful layers of a fresh caprese to the storied flavors of the signature MoMo’s Famoso, every dish captures a sense of rustic elegance and culinary passion.
• Zio's Pizzeria — Italian: Zio’s Pizzeria captures the heart of a classic neighborhood slice shop, where the intoxicating scent of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella draws you into a space filled with casual warmth. Oversized slices of specialty pies—from the creamy, herb-flecked Bianca to the bold tang of BBQ chicken—boast a perfect golden crunch, while tender, savory meatballs and pillowy garlic knots offer a comforting embrace of traditional flavors. Whether you’re grabbing a quick, cheese-laden slice on the go or settling in for a hearty plate of ravioli, every bite feels like a nostalgic celebration of soulful comfort food.
• Avoli Osteria — Italian: Bathed in a warm, amber glow, this intimate neighborhood gem transports diners to the heart of Northern Italy through the intoxicating aroma of hand-rolled pasta and slow-simmered ragus. The kitchen hums with the artistry of tradition, delivering plates of silk-thin noodles and seasonal ingredients that celebrate the beauty of simple, honest flavors. Each visit feels like a soulful invitation to linger over a crisp glass of wine in a space where rustic charm meets refined elegance.
• La Casa Pizzaria — Italian: Stepping into this neighborhood gem feels like entering a welcoming family home, where the comforting scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour hangs heavy in the warm, inviting air. Golden, hand-stretched crusts emerge from the oven with a perfect char, topped with vibrant sauces and artisanal ingredients that celebrate the simple joy of a well-made pie. Every slice offers a nostalgic taste of tradition, served with a genuine warmth that turns a simple meal into a soulful gathering.
• Spezia Omaha — Italian: Warmth radiates from the wood-fired oven at this polished destination, where the aroma of charred crusts and savory seafood sets the stage for a sophisticated yet inviting meal. Guests linger over bubbling artichoke crab dip and zesty fried calamari before diving into vibrant Mediterranean salads topped with wood-grilled salmon or artisanal flatbreads pulled hot from the hearth. The atmosphere strikes a perfect chord between casual comfort and refined elegance, offering a soulful escape defined by fresh ingredients and glowing hospitality.
• Tasty Pizza — Italian: The air is thick with the irresistible scent of bubbling mozzarella and charred dough, drawing neighbors into a space where the warm glow of the oven serves as the inviting heart of the room. Hand-stretched crusts emerge from the heat with a perfect leopard-spotted char, topped with vibrant sauces and artisanal ingredients that celebrate the simple joy of a well-crafted slice. This neighborhood gem offers a soulful sanctuary for those seeking the comfort of a piping-hot pie shared in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere.
• Pitch — Italian: Step into a high-energy haven where the smoky sweetness of bourbon-glazed bacon and the comforting warmth of melted cheese bread set the stage for a spirited culinary adventure. The kitchen masterfully balances bold, savory bites like spicy Calabrese meatballs and tangy stuffed peppadews with the refreshing crunch of vibrant, farm-fresh salads, creating a dynamic dining experience designed for sharing and celebration.
• Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano — Italian: Biaggi's Ristorante Italiano invites guests into a lively, sun-drenched space where the sizzle of calamari fritti and the sweet scent of warm apple crostata create an atmosphere of effortless hospitality. The kitchen balances rustic charm with modern flair, serving everything from delicate Sicilian-style swordfish to indulgent bacon-wrapped dates that celebrate bold, comforting flavors. It is a vibrant destination where shared plates of crispy fried ravioli and lump crab cakes set the stage for a memorable meal rooted in Italian tradition and contemporary warmth.
• Valentino's — Italian: Soft candlelight flickers against exposed brick walls at Valentino’s, where the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered ragu and toasted garlic sets the stage for an intimate evening of culinary indulgence. Hand-rolled pastas and tender, herb-crusted proteins are plated with artistic flair, capturing the soulful essence of Mediterranean tradition in every savory, sun-drenched bite. Whether tucked into a velvet booth for a quiet date or sharing a bottle of vintage red with old friends, guests find themselves transported to a world of timeless charm and genuine warmth.
• Vincenzo's — Italian: Vincenzo’s transports diners to a sanctuary of old-world charm where the air is perpetually perfumed with the scent of toasted garlic and slow-simmered sauces. Hand-rolled pastas and herb-crusted proteins are served amidst the soft glow of candlelight and the rhythmic clink of wine glasses, creating an atmosphere of timeless, spirited hospitality. It is a place where every meal feels like a soulful homecoming, inviting guests to linger over rich flavors and the warmth of shared tradition.
• Romeo's Mexican Food & Pizza — Mexican: This vibrant neighborhood haunt invites guests into a world where the savory scent of stone-baked pizza dough mingles with the smoky heat of authentic Mexican spices. Whether you’re tucking into a slice topped with bubbling cheese or savoring a plate of hand-crafted tacos, the unpretentious atmosphere and bold, comforting flavors create a festive dining experience that satisfies every craving.
• Copps Pizza — Italian: Golden-brown crusts emerge from the oven draped in bubbling mozzarella and signature dollops of rich cream cheese, offering a decadent local twist on the classic American pie. This vibrant neighborhood hub hums with the energy of shared slices and cold brews, inviting guests to settle into a space where every bite celebrates the comforting, soulful art of the perfect pizza.
• Godfather's Pizza — Italian: Step into a bustling haven of comfort where the aroma of golden-baked dough and savory sauces sets the stage for a truly indulgent feast. Towering specialty pies like the zesty Taco Pie and the loaded Humble Pie arrive at the table with thick, chewy crusts and a generous mountain of melted cheese, offering a bold and satisfying taste of classic Americana. It is a place where hearty portions and creative toppings bring people together for a meal that feels both timeless and celebratory.
• CRAVE — Japanese: CRAVE pulses with a festive, high-energy spirit, inviting guests to gather around sprawling grazing tables and vibrant party boards designed for the ultimate communal indulgence. The air hums with the sizzle of customizable fajita bars and the comforting aroma of golden-crusted pizzas, while zesty enchiladas and decadent mac and cheese bowls offer a soulful embrace of bold, familiar flavors. Whether diving into a bucket of crispy wings or sharing a meticulously crafted sandwich, every visit feels like a spirited celebration of shared moments and abundant, crowd-pleasing fare.
• Picklemans — American: This lively neighborhood haunt buzzes with the irresistible scent of hearth-toasted sandwiches and bubbling thin-crust pizzas emerging hot from the oven. Guests craft their perfect meal from a palette of crisp, vibrant greens and premium deli meats, finishing the experience with a decadent, house-baked cookie that offers a sweet, chewy end to a satisfyingly fresh lunch.
• Pizzeria Davlo — Italian: Pizzeria Davlo captures the heart of a classic neighborhood haunt, where the air is rich with the aroma of toasted crusts and the vibrant, zesty tang of their signature Flying Tomato sauce. Diners can dive into the indulgent, cheese-laden depths of an authentic Chicago-style deep dish or savor the satisfying snap of a golden thin-crust pie, all perfectly complemented by a cold draft beer and the easy, social hum of a welcoming local bar.
• Rocco's Pizza & Cantina — Italian: Step into a high-energy space where the sizzle of the pizza oven meets the rhythmic clink of margarita glasses, creating a festive backdrop for spirited social gatherings. Hand-tossed dough is transformed into charred, bubbling masterpieces, while the kitchen infuses classic comfort with bold, zesty accents that pair perfectly with a salt-rimmed cocktail or a frosty craft beer. The atmosphere hums with a casual, welcoming warmth that invites guests to linger over shared plates and lively conversation long after the last slice is gone.
• Take 5 Pizza — Italian: This lively neighborhood retreat invites guests to pause and recharge amidst the comforting aroma of hand-stretched dough and savory, bubbling toppings. Golden, blistered crusts emerge from the oven to anchor a menu of artisanal slices and creative combinations, creating a warm, unpretentious space where every bite feels like a well-deserved break from the bustle of the day.
• Smokin' Oak Wood-Fired Pizza — Italian: The air hums with the warmth of a roaring wood-fired oven, where the scent of seasoned oak and bubbling mozzarella invites guests into a space of rustic, fast-paced artistry. Hand-stretched dough transforms into charred, blistered masterpieces like the bold Smokey Dokey or the zesty Italian Stallion, complemented by golden, pull-apart garlic cheese breads that arrive hot and fragrant at the table. It’s a sensory celebration of fire and flavor, where every slice captures the smoky essence of traditional craftsmanship reimagined for the modern palate.
• Godfather's Pizza — Italian: Step into a warm, bustling atmosphere where the scent of baking dough and rich tomato sauce promises a truly substantial meal designed for sharing. Each signature pie is a masterpiece of abundance, featuring golden crusts loaded with everything from the zesty crunch of a Taco Pie to the savory layers of an Italian Sub, creating a comforting experience that honors the art of the generous slice.
• Williamsburg Pizza — Italian: This vibrant neighborhood haunt captures the soulful essence of a classic Brooklyn slice shop, where the rhythmic toss of dough and the warmth of glowing ovens create an inviting urban sanctuary. Thin, crackling crusts serve as a canvas for bright tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella, delivering a perfect balance of nostalgic comfort and artisanal flair in every hand-stretched bite.
• Johnny's Italian Steakhouse — Italian: Stepping into this modern-day supper club feels like a journey back to the glamorous era of the Rat Pack, where the smooth sounds of jazz and the cool glow of the Blue Bar create an atmosphere of timeless sophistication. The air carries the enticing aroma of sizzling, hand-cut steaks and rich, velvety pastas, inviting guests to linger over classic martinis in the comfort of plush leather booths and shimmering candlelight.