Best Pizza in Yorkville | Top 9 Spots

12 restaurants in Best Pizza in Yorkville | Top 9 Spots

• Horn's Hook Tavern — American · rated 5/5: This spirited neighborhood haunt captures the essence of a classic tavern, where warm lighting and the convivial clinking of glasses create an inviting backdrop for shared stories and hearty fare. Guests gather over generous platters of golden, brie-stuffed pretzels and crispy house-made potato skins, while the aroma of bubbling tavern pizzas and signature wings fills the air with a sense of rustic comfort.
• Donna Margherita — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into Donna Margherita feels like a warm embrace from a Neapolitan kitchen, where the intoxicating scent of blistered crusts and simmering San Marzano tomatoes fills the air. Beneath the glow of soft lighting, diners gather over rustic tables to share hand-stretched pizzas and silken pastas that celebrate the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of the Italian soul.
• Don Filippo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Don Filippo transports guests to a bustling Roman trattoria, where the intoxicating aroma of garlic, basil, and bubbling mozzarella drifts through a warm, candlelit dining room. Velvety ribbons of house-made pasta and crisp, charred pizzas showcase a mastery of simple, soul-warming flavors, creating a vibrant sanctuary where every meal feels like a spirited family celebration.
• York Ave Pizza — Italian · rated 4.5/5: York Ave Pizza captures the soulful energy of a neighborhood haunt, where the scent of bubbling cheese and toasted garlic spills onto the sidewalk to welcome every passerby. Inside, the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough leads to golden, thin-crust pies and steaming bowls of pasta that celebrate the vibrant, sun-drenched flavors of traditional Italian cooking. It is a convivial space where the warmth of the ovens and the lively hum of conversation create a dining experience that feels both timeless and deeply personal.
• San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this vibrant enclave feels like a journey to the heart of Salerno, where the rhythmic toss of dough and the golden glow of the wood-fired oven create a theater of authentic Italian craft. Pillowy, leopard-spotted pizzas arrive at the table alongside bowls of handmade pasta draped in rich, sun-ripened sauces, all served in a bustling atmosphere that hums with the convivial warmth of a Mediterranean home.
• Famous Famiglia Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Famous Famiglia Pizzeria captures the vibrant energy of a classic New York slice shop, where the air is thick with the comforting scent of garlic, oregano, and hand-tossed dough baking to a perfect golden crunch. Each slice offers a harmonious balance of tangy tomato sauce and bubbling, molten mozzarella, providing a nostalgic and soul-warming experience that brings the authentic spirit of an Italian kitchen to the heart of the city.
• Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Italian Village Pizzeria & Restaurant captures the heart of a traditional trattoria, where the golden glow of the oven and the intoxicating aroma of bubbling mozzarella create an immediate sense of home. Hand-stretched dough is transformed into crisp, blistered pizzas alongside bowls of silk-smooth pasta tossed in vibrant, herb-flecked sauces that honor time-tested recipes. This lively neighborhood anchor brings together the warmth of genuine hospitality and the soulful flavors of the Old World for an experience that feels both nostalgic and essential.
• Saba's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Saba’s Pizza serves as a flour-dusted sanctuary where the air is perpetually perfumed with the intoxicating scent of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge from the oven with a signature char, offering a satisfying crunch that gives way to layers of vibrant tomato sauce and hand-stretched cheese. It is a lively, welcoming space where the rhythmic energy of the kitchen and the warmth of a shared slice create an atmosphere of pure, unpretentious comfort.
• Giacomo's Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: The air at Giacomo's Pizza is a heady perfume of toasted yeast and roasted garlic, drawing guests into a vibrant space where the rhythmic toss of hand-stretched dough sets the tempo for the evening. Each pie emerges from the glowing oven with a perfectly blistered crust and a molten layer of artisanal cheeses, offering a soulful taste of Italy that transforms a simple meal into a spirited celebration of tradition and flavor.
• La Mia Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: The air at La Mia Pizza hums with the warmth of a roaring wood-fired oven, where hand-stretched dough transforms into charred, blistered masterpieces under the watchful eye of passionate pizzaiolos. Each slice offers a harmonious balance of tangy tomato sauce, fragrant basil, and molten cheese, inviting diners to linger over a glass of red in a space that feels like a spirited neighborhood gathering in the heart of Naples.
• LaRustica — Italian · rated 3.9/5: LaRustica transports diners to the heart of the Italian countryside, where exposed brick and the warm glow of a wood-burning oven create an intimate sanctuary for lovers of authentic flavor. Silk-smooth ribbons of pasta are hand-crafted daily and paired with slow-simmered ragùs, while artisanal pizzas boast the perfect blistered crust and the bright tang of sun-ripened tomatoes. It is a place where the clinking of wine glasses and the aroma of fresh basil invite long, soulful meals that turn every dinner into a spirited celebration of the Mediterranean table.
• Gotham Pizza — Italian · rated 3/5: This bustling urban slice shop hums with the energy of the city, drawing passersby in with the irresistible aroma of golden, bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour. A vibrant glass display showcases an array of artisanal pies, from the zesty heat of Buffalo chicken to the rustic, herb-flecked charm of a thick-crust Grandma square. Whether you are folding a classic pepperoni slice on the move or sharing a massive cheese pie with friends, every bite offers a quintessential taste of timeless New York pizza culture.