Best Sandwich in Milwaukee | Top 37 Spots

30 restaurants in Best Sandwich in Milwaukee | Top 37 Spots

• Dia Café — Mexican · rated 5/5: Dia Café serves as a vibrant sanctuary where the soulful aromas of Latin American street food fill the air, inviting guests to linger over a colorful spread of artisanal small plates. Golden-fried empanadas and crispy avocado tacos offer a satisfying crunch that gives way to tender, flavorful fillings, while molten pots of queso fundido and hand-patted pupusas bring a comforting, rustic warmth to the table. Every bite—from the delicate snap of yuca frita to the savory richness of Brazilian-style coxinha—celebrates a rich tapestry of regional traditions in a lively, welcoming setting.
• Caulfield's Wine Bar — American · rated 5/5: Soft lighting and the rhythmic clink of crystal define the atmosphere at Caulfield’s Wine Bar, an intimate sanctuary where guests unwind over artfully arranged boards of briny olives and toasted nuts. The kitchen elevates the evening with indulgent duck fat potato wedges and fragrant mussels, while velvety potato leek soup and roasted beets offer a grounded, seasonal warmth to the experience. Whether sharing a crisp flatbread or savoring delicate crab cakes, every bite is designed to complement a curated pour, making each visit a soulful celebration of refined, convivial dining.
• Brewski's Bar & Grill — American · rated 5/5: The air at Brewski's Bar & Grill is rich with the irresistible aroma of house-smoked pork belly and slow-cooked brisket, drawing guests into a lively space where comfort food is elevated to an art form. Friends gather over towering plates of brisket-loaded tochos and giant, salt-dusted Bavarian pretzels, while the kitchen turns out hearty prime rib sandwiches that pair perfectly with the convivial, high-energy atmosphere.
• Water Street Brewery — American · rated 5/5: This vibrant brewpub pulses with a convivial energy, where the warm glow of copper accents and the rhythmic clinking of pint glasses set the stage for a soulful, shared dining experience. The kitchen transforms classic comfort into an adventurous feast, serving up crispy, molten Wisconsin cheese curds alongside globally-inspired bites like savory short rib empanadas and tender churrasco skewers. Every plate, from the towering haystack onions to the delicate tempura Korean cauliflower, is crafted to complement the bold, house-brewed ales that flow freely in this spirited neighborhood anchor.
• Peter Sciortino's Bakery — Italian · rated 5/5: Step into a world where the sweet, nostalgic scent of toasted anise and buttery dough lingers in the air, drawing you toward counters brimming with golden-brown treasures. From the delicate, almond-scented crunch of amaretti to the flaky, fruit-filled layers of traditional kolacky and oversized bear claws, every bite celebrates the time-honored artistry of classic baking. Whether you are selecting a sugar-dusted turnover for a morning treat or a pound of crisp biscotti to share, this neighborhood gem offers a warm, sensory journey through the heart of an authentic Italian bakery.
• Kinship Café — American · rated 5/5: Kinship Café serves as a vibrant neighborhood hub where the sun-drenched space hums with the energy of a community gathering over creative, plant-forward comfort food. The kitchen reimagines familiar favorites through a modern lens, serving up everything from zesty, spice-rubbed "faux-rizo" burritos and tangy buffalo-drenched sandwiches to crisp, colorful bowls brimming with garden-fresh ingredients. Each plate balances bold, inventive flavors with a welcoming warmth, making it a destination where wholesome nourishment meets the soulful charm of a local hangout.
• Pilot Project — American · rated 4/5: This dynamic social hub hums with the energy of a creative laboratory, where the morning aroma of freshly roasted local coffee gives way to an evening of spirited discovery over shared tables. Guests can explore a boundary-pushing tap list of botanical hard kombuchas and craft brews while tucking into crusty artisanal sandwiches or vibrant seasonal salads that elevate traditional pub fare. The experience is one of relaxed innovation, offering a welcoming space to savor everything from a daring "Devious" cocktail to a sophisticated, non-alcoholic pint.
• Maggio's Wood Fired Pizza — Italian · rated 4/5: The warm glow of a wood-fired oven serves as the heart of this inviting neighborhood spot, where the air is thick with the irresistible aroma of bubbling mozzarella and toasted garlic bread bites. Artisanal Margherita pizzas with perfectly charred crusts share the table with hearty meatball sandwiches and vibrant Caprese salads, creating a rustic feast that celebrates simple, high-quality ingredients.
• The Wicked Hop — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant social hub pulses with energy, drawing guests into a high-ceilinged, sun-drenched space where the aroma of golden-fried delicacies and zesty salsas fills the air. The kitchen elevates classic comfort with indulgent, shareable plates like squeaky, beer-battered cheese curds and tender calamari fries, creating a playful atmosphere perfect for lively gatherings. Every bite, from the bold heat of the Quesadilla de Juarez to the salt-dusted crunch of a towering pretzel platter, captures the spirited and unapologetically indulgent essence of this neighborhood landmark.
• SmallPie — American · rated 4/5: Sunlight streams into this charming neighborhood nook, where the golden aroma of buttery, flaky pastry and griddled sandwiches creates an immediate sense of home. Diners tuck into hearty, hand-held treasures ranging from overstuffed savory handpies to creative melts that pair sharp cheddar with unexpected bursts of crisp apple or sweet blueberry. Whether you are starting the day with a rustic, crumbly bacon biscuit or lingering over a pesto-slathered sandwich, every bite offers a warm, artisanal embrace in a bright and welcoming space.
• Bavette La Boucherie — French · rated 4/5: Bavette La Boucherie blends the rugged soul of a traditional butcher shop with the polished elegance of a modern bistro, creating a space where artisanal craft is felt in every detail. The kitchen transforms humble ingredients into elevated experiences, from the golden crunch of beef fat fries and smoky trout deviled eggs to the delicate, melt-in-your-mouth artistry of hamachi crudo and hand-cut steak tartare. Warm rosemary focaccia and vibrant pickled vegetables round out a menu that celebrates bold, honest flavors in a setting that feels both intimate and effortlessly sophisticated.
• Milwaukee Waterfront Deli — American · rated 4/5: Sunlight glints off the nearby water as the morning bustle begins at this vibrant deli, where the savory aroma of griddled corned beef and freshly baked quiche invites guests into a lively, welcoming space. The kitchen turns out soulful, hand-crafted breakfast classics, ranging from the spicy zest of Huevos Rancheros to the nostalgic comfort of a Jersey pork roll. It is a place where hearty, protein-packed power bowls and buttery egg croissants are enjoyed against a backdrop of urban energy, offering a perfect start to the day.
• Benji's Deli — American · rated 4/5: Benji's Deli hums with the vibrant energy of a classic neighborhood gathering spot, where the comforting aroma of freshly toasted bagels and savory smoked lox greets early risers and midday diners alike. Heaping platters of premium meats and artisanal cheeses take center stage, transforming business breakfasts and social lunches into bountiful, shared feasts that celebrate the timeless appeal of a well-crafted sandwich.
• Roast Coffee Company — American · rated 4/5: The rich, nutty aroma of small-batch beans fills this sun-drenched sanctuary, where the rhythmic hiss of the steam wand signals the start of a perfect morning ritual. Velvety espresso drinks are crafted with artisanal precision and served alongside golden, buttery breakfast sandwiches, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that turns a simple coffee break into a moment of pure comfort.
• Rocket Baby Bakery — American · rated 4/5: The air at Rocket Baby Bakery is thick with the irresistible aroma of toasted butter and yeast, drawing guests into a bright space where artisanal craftsmanship is on full display. Flaky, golden croissants shatter at the first bite to reveal savory cheddar and smoky bacon, while rows of jewel-toned macarons and crusty, flour-dusted baguettes offer a perfect balance of sweet indulgence and rustic tradition. It is a neighborhood sanctuary where the comfort of a steaming bowl of scratch-made soup and the hearty satisfaction of a breakfast sandwich turn a simple morning stop into a warm, sensory ritual.
• BB's — American · rated 3/5: BB’s captures the heart of a classic morning retreat, where the air is thick with the savory scent of peppery gravy and the golden glow of perfectly toasted waffles. From the decadent richness of house-specialty Benedicts draped in velvety hollandaise to the bold, spicy kick of a Mexicana omelet, every plate is a generous tribute to the art of the hearty breakfast. Whether tucking into a towering "Warrior’s Feast" or savoring a delicate garden omelet, diners are wrapped in a bustling, soulful atmosphere that makes every meal feel like a homecoming.
• National Bakery & Deli — American · rated 3/5: Step into a nostalgic sanctuary of sweetness where the air is perfumed with rich cocoa and fresh cream, and glass cases shimmer with an array of meticulously layered tortes. Masterfully crafted creations like the velvety Sacher Torte and the vibrant Raspberry Ganache invite pure indulgence, showcasing a dedication to old-world pastry techniques and artisanal flair. Whether you are seeking a classic Boston Creme Pie or a custom-designed masterpiece, every visit feels like a celebration of the finer things in life.
• The Bread Pedalers — American · rated 3/5: The air at The Bread Pedalers is thick with the intoxicating aroma of toasted flour and yeast, where golden, crackling crusts give way to tangy sourdough infused with bold pairings like rosemary shallot and spicy garlic chili crisp. This artisanal haven transforms the morning routine into a sensory celebration, offering everything from the gooey, spice-laden swirls of oversized cinnamon rolls to garden-fresh bagel sandwiches that burst with vibrant, seasonal color.
• Gouda's Italian Deli — Italian · rated 3/5: Stepping into this bustling neighborhood deli feels like a nostalgic retreat where the air is thick with the savory perfume of aged provolone and freshly sliced Italian meats. Towering sandwiches like the bold Tommy Gun and the elegant Greta Garbo are piled high on crusty bread, offering a masterclass in Italian-American comfort that turns a simple lunch into a storied, flavorful feast.
• Sprocket Cafe — American · rated 3/5: This vibrant neighborhood hub hums with the energy of a local pit stop, where the aroma of toasted bagels and freshly brewed coffee invites guests into a space inspired by the spirit of the open road. Hearty, stacked sandwiches like the signature Bike Club offer a savory refuel alongside decadent slices of cake and sugar-dusted donuts that provide a sweet finish to any morning ride. The atmosphere remains effortlessly warm and community-focused, making it a sun-drenched corner to linger over a classic egg bagel or a crisp hummus and cucumber sandwich.
• Crafty Cow — American: This high-energy haunt celebrates the art of indulgence, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of sizzling pork belly and golden, beer-battered delights. Diners dive into mountains of loaded dilly fries and molten cheese curds drizzled in hot honey, each bite offering a satisfying crunch that gives way to rich, gooey centers. From the smoky depth of chicken-fried pork belly to the vibrant zest of elote-topped nachos, it’s a playful sanctuary for those seeking bold, soul-warming flavors and a spirited social atmosphere.
• McBob's Pub & Grill — American: McBob’s Pub & Grill is a lively neighborhood haunt where the comforting aroma of slow-cooked corned beef fills the air, drawing guests into its warm, unpretentious embrace. Patrons tuck into towering Reuben sandwiches and savory Irish meatloaf dinners that celebrate hearty, soul-warming flavors, while the satisfying crunch of dill pickle cheese curds provides the perfect salty companion to a cold pint. It is a place where every plate feels like a homecoming, blending Celtic tradition with the spirited, bustling energy of a classic corner pub.
• Mae Velma's Corned Beef — American: Stepping into Mae Velma’s Corned Beef feels like a warm embrace, where the savory aroma of slow-simmered brisket fills the air and the rhythmic sound of the carving knife promises a legendary meal. Each towering sandwich is a masterclass in texture, featuring ribbons of tender, salt-cured beef piled high and served alongside the refreshing, effervescent snap of a cold soda for the ultimate comfort-food experience.
• Fryerz — American: Sizzling griddles and the intoxicating scent of caramelized onions define this high-energy haunt, where the art of the cheesesteak is elevated through gooey layers of melted cheese and perfectly seared proteins. The kitchen balances the savory heat of the grill with the golden, seasoned crunch of classic fried chicken, offering a soulful experience that ranges from the iconic Gym Shoe sandwich to decadent, stacked burgers. It is a vibrant destination for unpretentious, flavor-packed comfort, where every toasted roll and crispy piece of chicken promises a satisfying, heart-warming escape.
• Riley's Social House — American: Riley’s Social House pulses with a welcoming energy, offering a modern take on the neighborhood gathering spot where the air is thick with the savory scent of seared Wagyu and spicy glazes. The kitchen masters the art of the elevated handheld, layering bold textures and global inspirations into everything from fiery Nashville hot chicken to the unexpected, tangy crunch of a steak and kimchi sandwich. Whether you’re tucking into street-style tacos or a hearty, pressed sandwich, every dish is crafted to be enjoyed in good company amidst the vibrant hum of a truly social dining experience.
• Aladdin - Taste of the East / PitaWorks — Middle Eastern: This vibrant culinary crossroads brings together the aromatic spices of the Levant and the smoky, soulful heart of American barbecue in a welcoming, high-energy atmosphere. Guests can indulge in the sizzle of tender chicken shawarma alongside fall-off-the-bone St. Louis ribs, or pair a fiery Nashville hot chicken sandwich with the creamy, golden comfort of ultimate mac and cheese. The journey concludes with a flourish of artisanal sweets, where delicate French macarons and decadent chocolate chunk cookies provide a refined finish to a menu defined by bold, global fusion.
• Onesto — Italian: Onesto invites guests into a polished, convivial atmosphere where the art of the shared plate is celebrated through vibrant colors and honest, soulful flavors. The kitchen transforms classic starters into sophisticated experiences, pairing the rich, melt-in-your-mouth decadence of glazed pork belly with the delicate crunch of golden crab cakes and the creamy indulgence of fresh burrata. Every dish, from the bright zest of sautéed calamari to the comforting warmth of seasonal soups, reflects a commitment to simple elegance and culinary craftsmanship.
• Smoke Shack — American: The air at Smoke Shack is thick with the intoxicating aroma of slow-smoldering hickory, drawing diners into a lively space where soulful Southern comfort meets bold, smoky innovation. Guests dive into indulgent plates of crispy fried green tomatoes and tender, caramelized burnt ends, or tackle towering, sauce-slathered sandwiches that celebrate the messy, glorious heart of traditional barbecue. From the creamy pull of pimento cheese to the inventive crunch of Kansas City eggrolls, every dish captures a sense of spirited backyard hospitality elevated by culinary craft.
• Flannery's Bar & Restaurant — American: Flannery's Bar & Restaurant serves as a lively neighborhood anchor where the hum of conversation mingles with the clink of glasses in a space designed for shared moments and communal celebration. Abundant platters of savory sausages, crisp garden vegetables, and creamy dips anchor the table, complemented by delicate silver dollar sandwiches and zesty tortilla pinwheels that evoke the effortless charm of a grand social gathering. This welcoming retreat invites guests to linger over chilled pasta salads and fresh fruit, offering a quintessential hospitality experience where every bite is meant to be passed and enjoyed together.
• Sweet Connie's Cafe — American: Sweet Connie's Cafe serves as a sun-drenched sanctuary for brunch lovers, where the comforting aroma of sizzling bacon and cinnamon-dusted French toast fills the air. The kitchen transforms morning classics into soulful masterpieces, from the velvety indulgence of Eggs Royale and creamy shrimp and grits to vibrant, sizzling vegan skillets that cater to every palate. Whether you’re diving into a towering hot stack or savoring a delicate spinach soufflé muffin, each bite captures the cozy, bustling essence of a neighborhood favorite.