Best Upscale Caribbean Restaurants in Prospect Heights | Upscale Caribbean Food

21 restaurants in Best Upscale Caribbean Restaurants in Prospect Heights | Upscale Caribbean Food

• Natural Blend — American · rated 5/5: Sunlight dances across the earthy, minimalist space of Natural Blend, where the invigorating aroma of cold-pressed ginger and simmering Caribbean spices creates an immediate sense of vitality. This neighborhood sanctuary transforms wholesome, plant-based ingredients into vibrant comfort food, offering everything from golden-crusted vegan patties to nutrient-rich bowls that nourish both the body and the spirit.
• The Simpson Restaurant and Bar — Seafood · rated 4.6/5: Located in the heart of Brooklyn at 673 Atlantic Ave, The Simpson Restaurant and Bar is a Caribbean-soul food gem. With a 4.6 rating and over 3,200 reviews, this seafood-centric spot offers a relaxed ambiance perfect for family dining and sports watching. Enjoy authentic dishes, delectable desserts, and a variety of cocktails. Parking is convenient with free street parking available. To book a table, call +1 347-763-2711.
• Caribbean Sweet Spice — Caribbean · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Caribbean Sweet Spice offers a delectable journey through Caribbean flavors. With a stellar 4.6 rating and a family-friendly ambiance, this charming restaurant delivers exceptional dishes from breakfast till dinner. Credit and debit cards are accepted, and patrons can enjoy takeout and curbside pickup options. Open daily, Caribbean Sweet Spice is a delightful addition to the Crown Heights neighborhood.
• Charm Bar & Restaurant — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Park Slope, Charm Bar & Restaurant effortlessly blends Caribbean and American flavors in a cozy, laid-back atmosphere. With highly-praised dishes like wings, salmon, lamb chops, and vegetarian options, it's a hit for brunch, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy outdoor seating, signature cocktails, and a vibrant ambiance with great music. Reservations are recommended for a quick and delightful dining experience.
• Island Shack — Seafood · rated 4.6/5: Island Shack in Fort Greene, Brooklyn, offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere perfect for families. Specializing in Trinidadian cuisine, the menu features mouth-watering dishes like roti, jerk chicken, and goat curry accompanied by refreshing drinks such as rum punch and sorrel. With attentive staff and a relaxed vibe, it's a delightful spot for both lunch and dinner. Prices range from $20-30, ensuring great value for a delicious culinary experience.
• The Islands — Seafood · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, The Islands serves up authentic Caribbean flavors in a cozy setting. Featuring popular dishes like jerk chicken and curried goat, this restaurant has become a neighborhood favorite. With a 4.5-star rating from over 500 reviews, diners appreciate its delicious fare, friendly service, and generous portions. Credit and debit cards are accepted, and they offer both dine-in and takeout options.
• Eve's Lounge — American · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the heart of Crown Heights, Eve's Lounge is a trendy spot offering delectable American bites, cocktails, and a vibrant atmosphere. Enjoy dishes like jerk chicken quesadillas and blackened salmon, paired with strong cocktails or a selection of beer and wine. With live performances and karaoke nights, it's a cozy, intimate venue where attentive staff ensure every visit is memorable. For reservations, call +1 347-442-5959.
• Puerto Viejo — Dominican · rated 4.3/5: Puerto Viejo transports diners to a sun-drenched corner of the Caribbean where rustic wood accents and vintage charm create a soulful backdrop for the vibrant pulse of Dominican hospitality. The air hangs heavy with the intoxicating aroma of slow-roasted pernil and garlic-infused mofongo, promising a feast of bold, savory flavors that celebrate the island’s rich culinary heritage. Guests find themselves enveloped in a communal energy that turns every meal into a spirited celebration of home and tradition.
• Carib Soul BK — American · rated 4.3/5: Welcome to Carib Soul BK-a vibrant dining spot nestled at 662 Washington Ave, Brooklyn. With a rating of 4.3 stars from 44 reviews, this inviting venue offers a delightful blend of American and Caribbean fare. Enjoy a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with outdoor seating, a children's menu, and a happy hour. Sip on wine, beer, or cocktails, and savor delectable brunches, lunches, and dinners. Open Wednesday to Sunday, Carib Soul BK promises great food, engaging service, and a lively ambiance.
• BK9 — Caribbean · rated 4.2/5: BK9 captures the soulful pulse of the Caribbean, where the air is perfumed with the smoky depth of pimento wood and the bright, fiery kick of scotch bonnet peppers. The sleek, contemporary space serves as a vibrant backdrop for an evening of shared plates and tropical-infused cocktails, blending island tradition with a sophisticated Brooklyn energy.
• TaylorMade Restaurant & Bar — American · rated 4.2/5: Located in the heart of Clinton Hill, TaylorMade Restaurant & Bar offers a laid-back ambiance perfect for enjoying authentic Jamaican comfort food. The diverse menu features classics like jerk chicken, curry goat, and oxtail, complemented by healthy options and quick bites. With its welcoming staff and family-friendly atmosphere, customers can enjoy a meal while watching sports or indulging in wine and desserts. Prices range from $10 to $20.
• 333 Lounge & Restaurant — American · rated 4.2/5: 333 Lounge & Restaurant is a laid-back venue in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn, offering an inviting ambiance perfect for savoring Caribbean and Southern-style dishes like chicken and waffles, jerk wings, and lamb sliders. With live entertainment, happy hour specials, and options for hosting events, it's a versatile spot for food, drinks, and memorable experiences. Whether you're there for the rum punch, jazz nights, or karaoke brunch, 333 Lounge guarantees good vibes and great times.
• DA PLACE CUISINE — American · rated 4.2/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, DA PLACE CUISINE offers a delightful journey into Jamaican cuisine with an array of classic favorites like oxtail and curry goat. With a welcoming atmosphere and a solid 4.2 rating from 107 reviews, this casual eatery is ideal for a quick takeout or a relaxed dine-in experience. Convenient operating hours from 6:30 AM to 9:30 PM make it an accessible spot for authentic flavors throughout the day.
• Charm — Thai · rated 4/5: Charm invites guests into a vibrant, stylish sanctuary where the air is thick with the savory scent of sizzling small plates and the hum of lively conversation. The kitchen artfully balances coastal freshness with soulful comfort, serving up golden-crisped cassava fritters and succulent Maryland crab cakes alongside tender, juice-dripping lamb sliders. Whether sharing a plate of delicate shrimp tempura or tucking into rich, savory pork and plantain cups, every bite feels like a curated celebration of bold textures and global inspirations.
• El Gran Castillo de Jagua — Spanish · rated 4/5: This vibrant neighborhood staple hums with a nostalgic energy, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of garlic-rubbed rotisserie chicken and slow-simmered beans. Guests settle into the unpretentious warmth of the dining room to feast on soulful Caribbean classics that capture the heart of home-cooked tradition in every steaming, golden plateful.
• Bird Pepper — Thai · rated 4/5: Bird Pepper transports diners to a sun-soaked island escape where the air is thick with the tantalizing aroma of jerk spices and toasted coconut. The kitchen turns out vibrant plates like zesty bird pepper shrimp and golden, coconut-crusted corn that burst with bold Caribbean flavors, while island-style pizzas offer a playful, tropical twist on coastal comfort. It is a lively sanctuary where every bite, from the succulent crab cakes to the crispy wing platters, feels like a rhythmic celebration of the tropics.
• SugarcaneBK — Caribbean (Wait, the list · rated 4/5: Welcome to SugarcaneBK, a stylish restaurant nestled in the heart of Park Slope, Brooklyn. This culinary gem delights with Caribbean-inspired dishes, drinks, and desserts. With a welcoming ambiance and attentive staff, it’s the perfect spot for gatherings with friends and family. Open Tuesday through Sunday, SugarcaneBK offers a vibrant dining experience you won’t want to miss.
• Taste of the City Lounge — American · rated 4/5: Taste of the City Lounge is a laid-back restaurant in Brooklyn offering American fare with a Caribbean twist. Enjoy everything from flavorful wings to exquisite desserts, all paired with delightful cocktails and wine. With a lively atmosphere perfect for group outings and sports watching, it's no wonder this spot boasts rave reviews and a solid 4-star rating. Located at 903 Franklin Ave, it's your go-to destination for memorable dining and vibrant vibes.
• Puerto Viejo — Mexican: This rustic Dominican bistro captures the soulful charm of a Caribbean home, where weathered wood and vintage accents create a warm, sun-dappled sanctuary in the heart of the neighborhood. The kitchen breathes life into traditional comfort with the rich aroma of slow-roasted pernil and garlic-infused mofongo, inviting guests to linger over plates of vibrant rice and beans and sweet, caramelized plantains. It is a place where every meal feels like a celebration of heritage, blending authentic island flavors with a cozy, intimate atmosphere that feels both timeless and welcoming.
• BK9 — Caribbean: This Brooklyn destination pulses with the vibrant energy of the Caribbean, blending sleek industrial-chic design with the soulful warmth of West Indian hospitality. The air carries the aromatic allure of pimento-rubbed jerk chicken and tender, slow-braised oxtail, inviting guests to linger over tropical-inspired cocktails in a space where modern sophistication meets the rhythmic heart of the islands.
• CARIBBEAN SWEET SPICE — American: Discover a taste of the Caribbean at *CARIBBEAN SWEET SPICE*, located at 2258 Albemarle Rd in Brooklyn, NY. This delightful restaurant offers both dine-in and takeout options, perfect for lunch or dinner. Nestled in the vibrant Flatbush neighborhood, it promises a flavorful escape with its authentic cuisine. Visit today and savor the rich, aromatic dishes that define Caribbean culinary tradition.