Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Bensonhurst | Upscale Italian Food

18 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Bensonhurst | Upscale Italian Food

• The Original John's Deli — American · rated 5/5: Stepping into this legendary neighborhood staple feels like entering the heart of an old-school Brooklyn deli, where the air is thick with the savory scent of sliced meats and the lively energy of a bustling counter. Towering heroes named after cinematic icons stretch across the workspace in epic proportions, layering premium cold cuts and zesty toppings onto crusty, fresh-baked bread to create massive masterpieces that range from two to six feet in length. Every overstuffed bite captures the bold, unapologetic spirit of a local institution dedicated to the art of the grand Italian-American sandwich.
• Panino Rustico — Italian · rated 4.6/5: This charming Italian enclave captures the soul of a traditional salumeria, where the rhythmic slicing of cured meats and the aroma of toasted focaccia create a bustling, warm atmosphere. Hand-pressed paninis overflow with sun-ripened ingredients and melted cheeses, offering a sensory journey through Italy’s regional flavors in every crisp, savory bite.
• Panino Rustico of Bensonhurst — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of Bensonhurst, Panino Rustico offers a delightful escape with its cozy, family-run atmosphere. Serving up Italian comfort food from breakfast to dinner, the menu boasts an array of sandwiches, crepes, salads, and paninis, catering to both vegetarian and healthy options. With a comfortable setting that's perfect for kids and a friendly staff, it's a wonderful spot for both dining in and takeout.
• Rob's of Brooklyn — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located at 8774B Bay Pkwy, Brooklyn, Rob's of Brooklyn is a New York-style pizzeria offering an extensive menu featuring a wide range of pizzas, pasta, salads, and sandwiches. It's a family-friendly spot known for its classic Brooklyn ambiance, popular dishes like the vodka slice and chicken roll, and fast, welcoming service. Catering to vegetarian and halal requests, Rob's is perfect for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.
• Federico’s Pizzeria — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Discover the authentic taste of Brooklyn at Federico’s Pizzeria, located at 2313 86th St. Renowned for its classic Brooklyn Pizza and delicious pasta made to order, this family-friendly spot boasts a 4.5-star rating. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or opting for delivery, Federico’s ensures a memorable meal with excellent service. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Federico’s also offers curbside pickup and serves wine to complement your dining experience.
• The Original John's Deli — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Stepping into this neighborhood landmark feels like a journey back in time, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of slow-roasted beef and the lively hum of a classic Italian-American counter. Artisan heroes come piled high with tender cuts and draped in rich, house-made gravies or pillows of fresh mozzarella, creating a soulful, messy indulgence that captures the essence of old-school comfort. It is a place where tradition is served on a roll, offering a bustling atmosphere that transforms a quick bite into a cherished local ritual.
• Bad Boys Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located at 2358 80th St in Brooklyn, Bad Boys Pizza is a classic pizza restaurant beloved by locals. With a commendable rating of 4.4 from 231 reviews, the establishment offers a family-friendly atmosphere and convenient takeout and delivery options. Open Monday through Saturday, 10:30 AM to 9:30 PM, Bad Boys Pizza accepts credit, debit, and NFC payments, ensuring a hassle-free dining experience.
• Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in Bensonhurst, Papa Mikes Brick Oven Pizza offers a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for families. This pizzeria serves up a variety of Italian comfort foods, including delicious pizzas, garlic knots, and chicken rollatini. They also cater to vegetarian and vegan diners. With friendly service and a welcoming staff, it's a great spot for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite. Most meals range from $10 to $20.
• John's Deli — American · rated 4.4/5: Discover the charm of John's Deli, a family-owned sandwich shop in Gravesend since 1968. Renowned for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, this Brooklyn staple offers a wide array of hot and cold sandwiches, salads, pastas, and desserts. Notable favorites include the roast beef sandwich and chicken parm. With a casual, old-school vibe, John's Deli provides dine-in, takeout, and catering services, ensuring a delightful experience every visit.
• Best Pizza & Chicken — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Located in the heart of Bensonhurst, Best Pizza & Chicken offers a diverse menu that goes beyond just delightful pizzas. With halal options that include fried chicken, burgers, and more, this cozy spot caters to a variety of tastes. Praised for its exceptional service and reasonably priced meals, it’s the perfect place for a family lunch or an easy takeout. Kids are welcome, and the restaurant even serves wine for a complete dining experience.
• Mamma Mia Pizza — Italian · rated 4.3/5: Mamma Mia Pizza in Brooklyn is the go-to spot for classic NY-style pizza and Italian fare. With a menu that features pizza slices, calzones, heroes, and pasta platters, there's something for everyone. Popular items include pepperoni pizza and chicken wings. This casual eatery offers both takeout and delivery, making it a convenient choice for families. Enjoy affordable, delicious meals, with kids' options and catering available.
• Pizza D'Amore — Italian · rated 4.2/5: Located in the heart of Caesar's Bay shopping center, Pizza D'Amore serves up an impressive array of delicious pizzas, chicken rolls, wraps, and salads. Boasting a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere and excellent customer service, it's an ideal spot for both dining in and taking out. With generous portions and a classic NY vibe, plus convenient free parking, this casual pizzeria is a beloved local favorite.
• La Bella Pizza Express — Italian · rated 4.2/5: La Bella Pizza Express, located at 2178 86th St 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, specializes in serving mouth-watering pizza, pasta, and salads. With a user rating of 4.2 from over 587 reviews, it's a favorite for families and groups. Open daily from 11:00 AM, La Bella offers a kid-friendly menu and various options for takeout and delivery. Don't miss out on their delectable desserts and cozy dining experience. For more details, call +1 718-372-2200.
• Pizza Den — Italian · rated 4.2/5: 🍕 **About Pizza Den:** Nestled in Brooklyn, Pizza Den offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for families. Specializing in a variety of specialty pizzas, calzones, and rice balls, this cozy spot has earned a 4.2-star rating from over 450 satisfied customers. They're open late, ensuring fresh, hot slices are always within reach. Conveniently located at 8521 18th Ave, this pizzeria is a must-visit for an authentic Brooklyn pizza experience.
• Chequito’s Mexican Food And Pizzeria — Mexican · rated 4/5: Nestled at 2625 86th St, Brooklyn, Chequito’s Mexican Food and Pizzeria blends the best of Mexican and Italian cuisines. With a warm, family-friendly atmosphere and a variety of delectable dishes, it's a local favorite. Enjoy brunch, lunch, or dinner with convenient options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Rated 4 stars by patrons, this charming eatery is perfect for groups and offers a delightful array of desserts and coffee. Reserve your spot today by calling +1 718-676-2698.
• Pino Pizza — Italian · rated 3.9/5: Welcome to Pino Pizza, a cozy pizza restaurant in Bath Beach, Brooklyn. Serving up delicious pies and quick bites for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Pino Pizza offers a variety of specialty options like buffalo chicken pizza and grilled vegetable pizza. The informal atmosphere and swift service make it a great spot for a casual meal, with menu prices typically ranging from $10 to $20. Enjoy small plates, along with a selection of beer and wine, perfect for pairing with your meal. Families are welcome, and the restaurant is conveniently open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM. Visit us at 2025 Bath Ave or explore our menu online at pinopizzamenu.com.
• R&Z Pizza — Italian · rated 3.3/5: Located at 1564 W 10th St, Brooklyn, R&Z Pizza is a welcoming spot for delicious pizza. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 8:30 PM, it offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. The restaurant is kid-friendly and accepts both cash and credit cards. With a 3.3-star rating, R&Z Pizza is praised for its tasty fare and generous portions of cheese. Whether you're local or just passing through, R&Z Pizza is a convenient choice for your next meal.
• Fortunato's Pizza — Italian: Nestled at 6526 Metropolitan Avenue in Middle Village, NY, Fortunato's Pizza offers a welcoming spot for delicious dining. Whether you’re in the mood for lunch, dinner, or a quick takeout, this operational gem has got you covered. Its convenient location and friendly atmosphere make it a perfect place to enjoy a meal in the heart of Queens.