Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Upscale Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Italian Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Upscale Italian Food

• Macario — Italian · rated 5/5: Macario transports diners to the heart of Italy, where the soft glow of candlelight dances across rustic wooden tables and the air is thick with the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered ragù and fresh basil. Hand-rolled pastas take center stage, each ribbon and fold capturing the essence of heritage recipes, while vibrant seasonal ingredients are transformed into plates that celebrate the simple, bold flavors of the Mediterranean. It is a sanctuary of soulful hospitality, where every glass of robust red wine and every shared plate of antipasti invites guests to linger long into the evening.
• Bobbi's Italian Beef — American · rated 5/5: Bobbi's Italian Beef captures the soulful energy of a Chicago neighborhood joint, where the air is thick with the savory scent of slow-simmered beef and the spicy kick of house-made giardiniera. From the buttery, molten depths of a deep-dish pizza to the satisfying snap of a classic Vienna Beef dog, every bite is a tribute to Midwestern comfort, best enjoyed with a frosty craft beer and the lively hum of a bustling dining room.
• Sociale — Italian · rated 5/5: Bathed in the warm glow of amber lights, Sociale captures the spirit of a bustling European bistro where the clink of wine glasses provides a rhythmic backdrop to an evening of shared discovery. The kitchen transforms seasonal ingredients into rustic, soul-warming plates designed for the center of the table, inviting guests to linger over vibrant flavors and spirited conversation.
• Brooklyn Social — American · rated 5/5: Brooklyn Social captures the soulful intersection of a moody New York lounge and a spirited Italian aperitivo bar, where low lighting and the rhythmic shake of cocktails set a sophisticated, communal tone. The bar serves as a liquid map of inspiration, from the spicy warmth of Matt’s Ginger Old Fashioned to the bright, citrusy notes of a Sicilian Fizz that evokes the cinematic charm of a Fellini classic. It is an atmospheric retreat designed for lingering over inventive pours like the smoky Blonde Mezcal Negroni, offering a refined yet effortless escape in the heart of the neighborhood.
• Vinny's Restaurant — Italian · rated 5/5: Vinny’s Restaurant welcomes guests with the comforting embrace of a neighborhood classic, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of slow-simmered garlic and toasted herbs. Generous plates of soul-warming comfort food take center stage, from silken pastas draped in rich sauces to golden-crusted favorites that celebrate the timeless appeal of home-style cooking. Between the lively hum of conversation and the steady flow of wine, every meal feels like a seat at a bustling family table where tradition and hospitality are served in equal measure.
• Panzerotti Bites — Italian · rated 5/5: This vibrant spot celebrates the golden, crispy artistry of Pugliese street food, where the irresistible aroma of dough frying to a perfect crunch invites you into a world of savory, handheld delights. Each handcrafted pocket yields to a molten heart of gooey cheese and rich fillings, ranging from the classic simplicity of tomato and mozzarella to sophisticated layers of earthy porcini, silky mortadella, or zesty artichokes. It is a warm, sensory journey to the sun-drenched streets of Southern Italy, offering a comforting bite of tradition in every steam-filled turnover.
• Caputo's Fine Foods — Italian · rated 5/5: Stepping into this neighborhood treasure feels like a journey to an old-world Italian market, where the air is thick with the savory perfume of hanging salamis and sharp, aged cheeses. Behind the bustling counters, skilled hands craft overstuffed sandwiches on crusty bread and package house-made specialties, while shelves lined with golden olive oils and imported delicacies promise a true taste of Mediterranean heritage.
• Famous House of Pizza & Calzone — Italian · rated 5/5: The golden, crackling crust of a deep-fried calzone yields to a molten heart of savory fillings at this neighborhood institution, where the comforting aroma of bubbling mozzarella and toasted dough fills the air. From the airy, charred edges of a Neapolitan pie to the hearty, pan-baked crunch of a classic Grandma’s slice, every dish celebrates a legacy of hand-crafted Italian-American comfort. Crispy, golden rice balls serve as the perfect companion, offering a satisfying snap that reveals a rich and savory center in every bite.
• Travel Bar — American · rated 5/5: Travel Bar invites guests on a flavorful journey where the warmth of a neighborhood local meets a curated selection of global comfort classics. The air hums with conversation as friends share bountiful meat and cheese boards and vibrant Mediterranean plates, or tuck into smoky pulled pork sandwiches and iconic, crispy-crust pizza slices. It is a soulful, eclectic retreat where every dish, from the creamy spinach artichoke dip to a nostalgic hot dog, celebrates the simple joy of a well-traveled palate in a relaxed, communal setting.
• Savelli — Italian · rated 5/5: Savelli captures the soulful essence of a modern Italian kitchen, where the golden crunch of savory rice balls and the rich, nostalgic aroma of slow-simmered meatballs create an immediate sense of home. The experience centers on artfully plated shared treasures, from delicate zucchini soufflés and silky beef carpaccio to vibrant octopus salads that sing with Mediterranean freshness. It is a place where time slows down over overflowing boards of artisanal cheeses and chilled wine, offering a refined yet deeply comforting escape for the spirited diner.
• Amano — Italian · rated 5/5: Sunlight dances across flour-dusted counters in this vibrant, open-concept space where the rhythmic artistry of handmade pasta-making serves as the soulful heart of the experience. Guests linger over seasonal plates that marry the chewy perfection of artisanal dough with bright, garden-fresh ingredients, all within an atmosphere that hums with the warm, inviting energy of a modern craft workshop.
• Monteleone's Bakery & Cafe — Italian (Monteleone is an Italian · rated 5/5: The air is thick with the sweet perfume of powdered sugar and freshly pulled espresso, welcoming guests into a charming neighborhood haven that feels like a nostalgic trip to an old-world Italian pasticceria. Glass cases overflow with jewel-like pastries and crisp, cream-filled cannoli, while sun-drenched cafe tables invite lingering conversations over artisanal coffee and rustic, hand-crafted sandwiches.
• Cremini's — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Cremini’s transports diners to a sun-dappled corner of Italy, where the warm glow of the dining room and the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered sauces create an immediate sense of home. The kitchen honors tradition through artfully prepared plates of silken pasta and golden, crisp specialties that burst with the rustic, soulful flavors of the Marche region. It is an intimate sanctuary where every meal feels like a celebration of heritage, inviting guests to linger over vibrant wines and shared stories long after the last bite.
• Panzerotti Bites — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Located at 235 Smith St, Brooklyn, Panzerotti Bites serves up authentic Italian flavors with their signature panzerotti-delicious dough pockets with savory and sweet fillings. The cozy spot is perfect for families and offers a welcoming atmosphere with outdoor seating. Savor expertly crafted dishes alongside a selection of wine, beer, and coffee. Highly rated by locals and visitors alike, this gem is a must-try for anyone in the area.
• Aromi — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Aromi, located at 552 Court St, Brooklyn, is a charming Italian restaurant that boasts a stellar 4.9 rating from over 300 satisfied diners. Renowned for its wood-fired pizzas and diverse pasta offerings, it's a perfect spot for families with a dedicated children's menu. With options for curbside pickup, outdoor seating, and free street parking, Aromi ensures a delightful dining experience. Visit www.arominyc.com or call +1 347-529-5752 for reservations.
• 532 Court Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled at 532 Court St, Brooklyn, 532 Court Restaurant offers an upscale yet welcoming dining experience. Open Thursday to Sunday, it’s perfect for brunch, dinner, or private events. Boasting glowing reviews, a 4.8-star rating, curbside pickup, and delivery options, it’s family-friendly and great for watching sports. Accepts credit and debit cards. Street and garage parking available. Don't miss their delectable desserts!
• Farina nyc — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in Brooklyn's Red Hook neighborhood, Farina NYC offers authentic Italian fare with a charming ambiance. This family-friendly restaurant boasts a 4.8-star rating from delighted patrons. Enjoy a perfectly crisp pizza, flavorful pasta genovese, and delectable desserts. With options for dine-in, curbside pickup, and delivery, plus a variety of payment methods, Farina NYC ensures a seamless dining experience.
• Cafe Spaghetti — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into this sun-drenched neighborhood sanctuary feels like a warm embrace, where the nostalgic aroma of garlic and slow-simmered pomodoro drifts through a space filled with the soft hum of happy conversation. Golden strands of house-made pasta are tossed in vibrant, soul-warming sauces that celebrate the rustic simplicity of the Italian pantry, offering a convivial dining experience that captures the heart of a traditional family Sunday.
• Barbalu Brooklyn — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Welcome to Barbalu Brooklyn, a delightful family-owned Italian restaurant nestled in Boerum Hill. Known for its homemade pastas, pizzas, and bread, Barbalu offers a cozy, inviting atmosphere perfect for family outings. Menu standouts include the cavatelli with mixed mushrooms and black truffle, and the ravioli. With vegan and vegetarian options, happy hour specials, and rave reviews of its desserts, it’s a must-visit!
• Defonte's Sandwich Shop — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located in the heart of Red Hook, Brooklyn, Defonte's Sandwich Shop has been a cherished spot for classic Italian heros since the 1920s. Known for quick service and an unpretentious vibe, this cash-only standout serves up generously stuffed sandwiches, including favorites like the roast beef, fried eggplant, and chicken cutlet with vodka sauce. Perfect for a fast and satisfying breakfast or lunch, customers can find hearty bites from 6:00 AM to 4:00 PM, Monday through Saturday. (Log and view their location on [Google Maps](https://maps.google.com/?cid=15346702029336122365))
• AMANO — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Amano in Carroll Gardens is a versatile spot that delights from breakfast through dinner. With popular dishes like meatballs, charcuterie, and focaccia, accompanied by a varied drink menu featuring martinis and beer, it's perfect for any time of day. Enjoy a cozy atmosphere complete with Wi-Fi, high chairs for kids, and speedy service. Reservations are available at this warmly inviting eatery and cocktail bar. Call +1 929-250-2525.
• MAMA MARIA'S — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Discover Mama Maria's, a laid-back Italian gem in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. Specializing in mouth-watering pizzas and pastas, this cozy spot also serves up beloved classics like calamari, clams oreganata, and tiramisu. Enjoy a glass from their full bar or bring the family; they welcome children with high chairs. Open for lunch and dinner, reservations are accepted. Save room for dessert!
• Mama Capri — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Discover the charm of Mama Capri, an Italian gem in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn. This cozy, casual spot features a fireplace, bar, and outdoor seating. The diverse menu offers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, plus a kids' menu. Popular dishes include risotto, burrata, and spaghetti allo scoglio. The restaurant is family-friendly and perfect for solo dining. Expect attentive service and a delightful dining experience.
• Smith Street Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Smith Street Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria serving up traditional Italian pies with a New York twist for both lunch and dinner. Located at 311 Smith St, Brooklyn, this charming spot is praised for its friendly staff, fast service, and delicious offerings like pepperoni, vodka, and sausage pizzas. Perfect for kids and reasonably priced, this local gem captures the essence of NYC-style pizza in an unpretentious setting.
• Table 87 Coal Oven Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: The warm glow of the coal-fired hearth serves as the centerpiece of this bustling eatery, where the scent of charred crust and simmering tomato sauce invites guests into a world of artisanal craftsmanship. Every slice emerges from the intense heat with a signature blistered crunch, topped with velvety mozzarella and fresh basil to create a rustic, flavor-forward experience that celebrates the timeless tradition of the perfect pie.
• Marco Polo Ristorante — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Marco Polo Ristorante feels like a journey to a refined Roman villa, where the warm glow of candlelight dances across white linens and the air is thick with the savory perfume of roasting garlic and fresh herbs. The kitchen honors tradition through silken ribbons of house-made pasta tossed in rich, soulful ragus and vibrant coastal flavors that sing of the Italian seaside. It is a sanctuary of conviviality, where the clink of wine glasses and the artful presentation of each plate invite diners to linger over a true celebration of the Mediterranean spirit.
• Savelli — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Savelli captures the soul of the Italian countryside, where the warm aroma of wood-fired crusts and garden-fresh herbs drifts through an intimate, candlelit space. Guests are treated to a masterclass in simplicity, from delicate, hand-pinched ravioli swimming in browned butter to robust red wines that perfectly complement the kitchen’s rustic, heart-led creations. It is a vibrant
• Bobbi's Italian Beef — American · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Bobbi’s Italian Beef, the air is thick with the savory perfume of slow-roasted beef and aromatic spices simmering in a rich, golden jus. Here, crusty Italian loaves are piled high with tender, paper-thin ribbons of meat and finished with the vibrant crunch of spicy giardiniera, offering a messy, soul-satisfying bite that captures the heart of classic American comfort.
• Café Mars — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Bathed in the glow of neon and buzzing with a playful, avant-garde energy, this vibrant eatery reimagines the Italian dining experience as a whimsical technicolor dream. The kitchen transforms nostalgic flavors into inventive, artful plates that surprise the palate, inviting diners to linger over bold textures and unexpected twists in a space that feels like a high-spirited dinner party.
• Bass & Bourbon — Seafood · rated 4.6/5: Located at 113 Hamilton Ave in Brooklyn, Bass & Bourbon offers a modern and airy dining experience with a rooftop terrace. Open for lunch, brunch, and dinner, the restaurant serves a diverse menu that includes pizza, pasta, fish, and vegetarian options. Families are welcome, street parking is available, and valet service adds a touch of convenience. With a strong 4.6 rating from over 380 reviews, it's easy to see why this spot is favored by many. Enjoy outdoor seating, takeout, curbside pickup, and a fine selection of wine, beer, and cocktails.