Best Upscale Mexican Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Upscale Mexican Food

30 restaurants in Best Upscale Mexican Restaurants in Carroll Gardens | Upscale Mexican Food

• Cafecito Social — Mexican · rated 5/5: Sunlight dances through this vibrant sanctuary where the rich, volcanic heritage of Guatemala is celebrated in every meticulously poured cup. The air carries the intoxicating aroma of high-altitude beans, inviting guests to explore a sensory map of the country through the chocolatey depths of Antigua blends and the bright, complex notes of Huehuetenango and Atitlán. It is a warm, community-focused space that transforms a simple morning ritual into a curated journey across Central America’s most storied coffee regions.
• Las Melecias — Mexican · rated 5/5: Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 237 9th St, Las Melecias delights with authentic Mexican flavors. Open daily with convenient hours, this mom-and-pop spot is a hit for both dine-in and takeout. Reviewers rave about the tamales and friendly service. Enjoy delicious food with swift takeaway options and a diverse payment system that includes debit and NFC. Las Melecias is your go-to for a genuine culinary experience.
• El Mexicano Restaurante & Cafe Inc. 5 — Mexican · rated 4.9/5: Nestled at 230 Hoyt St, Brooklyn, El Mexicano Restaurante & Cafe Inc. is a beloved spot for authentic Mexican cuisine. Highly rated at 4.9 stars from 62 reviews, it offers delicious meals perfect for lunch or dinner, with delectable desserts and coffee. The family-friendly restaurant takes credit, debit, and NFC payments, providing a convenient experience. Enjoy dine-in, takeout, and delivery options every day but Sunday.
• Ruta Oaxaca — Mexican · rated 4.7/5: Step into a vibrant sanctuary where the smoky allure of mezcal and the complex, earthy aroma of slow-simmered moles transport you straight to the heart of Southern Mexico. Hand-painted tiles and warm lighting set the stage for a culinary journey through Oaxacan traditions, where every bite of tender braised meats and house-made tortillas feels like a celebration of ancestral heritage.
• Someday Bar NYC — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Boerum Hill, Someday Bar NYC offers a cozy, laid-back vibe perfect for unwinding. With a robust selection of craft beers, cocktails, and hard cider, this neighborhood gem also boasts delicious food options like tacos, buffalo wings, chicken tenders, and deviled eggs. Enjoy happy hour specials, bar games, live entertainment, and drag shows, all backed by fast, friendly service.
• Alma Negra — Mexican · rated 4.7/5: Located in the heart of Gowanus, Alma Negra offers a cozy ambiance with a contemporary twist on Mexican cuisine. Enjoy locally sourced share plates featuring popular dishes like quesadillas, fish tacos, and guacamole, alongside a fine selection of tequila and mezcal. With attentive staff, swift service, and options for brunch, dinner, and happy hour, it's an ideal spot for gatherings and casual outings. Reserve at +1 917-909-0339.
• Los Hermanos Coffe and taqueria — Mexican · rated 4.7/5: Situated at 142 W 9th St in Brooklyn, Los Hermanos Coffee and Taqueria offers a delightful culinary experience. Highly rated at 4.7 stars, this family-friendly spot serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner with various payment options. Known for its delicious tacos, burritos, and desserts, it caters to both vegetarians and meat lovers. With curbside pickup, takeout, and delivery options, it's perfect for any dining need.
• Chuzo Culture — Mexican · rated 4.7/5: Located at 412 5th Ave, Brooklyn, Chuzo Culture offers an inviting setting for family and friends. With a high rating of 4.7 from 72 reviews, it's clear that guests love its coastal Ecuadorian cuisine. Enjoy free street parking, sports viewing, and happy hour from 4-7 PM. The menu caters to all, including kids, vegetarians, and even offers dessert and wine! Open daily, Chuzo Culture truly embodies a vibrant dining experience. For reservations, call +1 718-398-4300.
• Leyenda — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: Located at 221 Smith St in Brooklyn, Leyenda is a relaxed eatery offering exquisite Latin American cuisine and inventive cocktails. With a cozy patio, this spot is perfect for leisurely outdoor dining. Enjoy happy hour specials, delightful desserts, and an enticing menu of small plates. Open weekdays from 5:00 PM and weekends from 1:00 PM, Leyenda provides a vibrant atmosphere that’s ideal for an unforgettable social outing.
• Bar San Miguel — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: Bar San Miguel, located at 307 Smith St, Brooklyn, is a charming spot renowned for its tequila-based craft cocktails and delectable Mexican tapas. With a welcoming, rustic-chic ambiance and a beautiful back patio, this local gem is perfect for family dinners and friendly gatherings. Highlights include their brunch and happy hour offerings, outdoor seating, and a menu that caters to children. Rated 4.6 stars with over 380 reviews, it’s known for exceptional service and delightful dishes. For reservations, call +1 718-576-3852.
• Purépecha — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: Purépecha is a vibrant Mexican restaurant located at 213 Smith St, Brooklyn. With a user rating of 4.6 and 256 reviews, it offers a casual and welcoming experience complete with delicious tacos and housemade tortillas. The colorful, mural-adorned space is perfect for families and children. Open daily, Purépecha serves lunch, dinner, brunch, and delightful desserts, along with a selection of wine, beer, coffee, and cocktails. Reservations are accepted, making it an ideal spot for your next meal out.
• Verde — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Verde pulses with the vibrant energy of a sun-drenched cantina, where the air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of charred chilies and freshly squeezed lime. Hand-pressed tortillas cradle slow-braised meats and zesty, garden-fresh salsas, while the rhythmic clink of ice in salt-rimmed glasses sets the stage for an evening of bold, authentic flavors. It is a spirited sanctuary where every bright, herbaceous bite and smoky sip of artisanal mezcal brings the soul of Mexico to life.
• Claro — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Sun-drenched Oaxacan soul fills this rustic sanctuary, where the rhythmic patting of hand-pressed tortillas and the smoky allure of a wood-fired hearth set a soulful, inviting tempo. Rich, velvety moles and charred seasonal treasures celebrate the deep traditions of the Mexican highlands, encouraging guests to linger over artisanal mezcals in a lush, tile-adorned backyard that feels worlds away from the city bustle.
• Mexiana — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Discover Mexiana, a delightful Mexican restaurant nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 237 9th St. Boasting a 4.5-star rating from 64 satisfied diners, Mexiana excels in serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner that's both fresh and flavorful. Families are welcome, and there's an array of vegetarian dishes and desserts to enjoy. Convenient payment options and takeout services make it easy to savor their tasty fare.
• White Maize TO GO — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: **About White Maize TO GO** White Maize TO GO is a casual, counter-serve eatery in New York City, offering a delightful taste of Venezuelan cuisine. Known for its delicious arepas, cachapas, and empanadas, the restaurant is a neighborhood gem. It boasts a 4.5-star rating from 80 reviews and is family-friendly with outdoor seating available. Conveniently take advantage of curbside pickup, dine-in, or delivery options. Credit and debit cards are accepted. Visit us at 228 W 18th St #1, New York.
• White Maize — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: White Maize, located at 277 Smith St, Brooklyn, offers a cozy, casual setting to enjoy traditional Venezuelan cuisine. Featuring dishes like arepas, cachapas, and tequeños, alongside beer and wine, this restaurant is perfect for families and food enthusiasts. With a 4.5-star rating and friendly service, White Maize ensures a delightful dining experience. They also provide takeout and delivery options. Visit White Maize for a taste of Venezuela in Carroll Gardens!
• Portal Latino — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: Located at 217 Smith St, Brooklyn, Portal Latino is a welcoming spot renowned for its authentic Dominican cuisine. Open daily from 7:00 AM to 9:30 PM, this family-friendly restaurant offers a variety of dishes, with standout favorites like chicharrón de pollo and mondongo soup. Guests can also enjoy delicious desserts and coffee. With options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, and various payment methods accepted, it’s a convenient choice for any meal.
• Buddy's Burrito & Taco Bar — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in Brooklyn's Cobble Hill, Buddy's Burrito & Taco Bar offers a cozy, colorful atmosphere and a delightful menu of Mexican favorites. Known for its freshly-prepared comfort food, patrons rave about the generous portions of burritos, tacos, and nachos, including vegetarian and vegan options. With friendly staff and a kid-friendly menu, Buddy's is the perfect spot for a quick, satisfying meal.
• El Olomega Pupusas — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: El Olomega Pupusas in the Red Hook Food Vendors Marketplace offers a laid-back vibe perfect for solo diners. This Salvadoran spot, known for its delicious pupusas, also serves plantains and paratha. With friendly staff and affordable prices, it has become a staple for many. Open on weekends, it's an ideal place for a flavorful and quick bite.
• Fast and Fresh Burrito Deli — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: Tucked away in Boerum Hill, Fast and Fresh Burrito Deli is a charming, family-owned Mexican restaurant offering a delightful array of burritos, tacos, tamales, tortas, and quesadillas, along with vegetarian and breakfast options. The cozy space features a seasonal backyard patio, perfect for groups and families. Enjoy fresh, flavorful dishes while unwinding in a laid-back atmosphere.
• Mex Carrol's Diner — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Mex Carrol's Diner blends the nostalgic, welcoming warmth of a classic neighborhood eatery with the bold, sun-drenched flavors of traditional Mexican soul food. The air hums with the sizzle of seasoned meats and the bright scent of fresh cilantro, as guests tuck into vibrant plates that balance smoky chiles with the cooling zest of lime. It is a lively, unpretentious retreat where every meal feels like a festive celebration of spice and community.
• Alma BK — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the scenic Columbia Street Waterfront District, Alma BK offers a delightful blend of traditional Mexican cuisine and breathtaking rooftop views of Manhattan. Renowned for its margaritas and fajitas, this cozy eatery provides brunch, lunch, and dinner, along with tasty vegetarian and dessert options. With a 4.3-star rating from 838 reviews, Alma BK promises a versatile dining experience, complete with outdoor seating, takeout, and delivery services.
• Solber Pupusas — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Discover Solber Pupusas, a family-run food truck nestled at the corner of Bay and Clinton St in Brooklyn, delighting locals and visitors with authentic Salvadoran cuisine. Their menu, featuring tamales, chorizo, and their famed pupusas, offers a satisfying dining experience both for families and groups. Open from Sunday to Friday, this cozy spot boasts a 4.3-star rating from satisfied patrons.
• La Parada Express — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Located at 460 3rd Ave in Brooklyn, La Parada Express is a delightful Spanish restaurant with a solid 4.3 rating based on 81 reviews. Known for its generous portions and fresh ingredients, this spot is perfect for both families and groups. Open Monday to Saturday from 6:30 AM to the evening, it offers a menu spanning breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. Enjoy the convenience of takeout and delivery, and savor their delicious desserts. The friendly staff and efficient service ensure a pleasant dining experience. Don’t forget, they accept credit, debit, and NFC payments!
• Cubana Cafe — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Cubana Cafe transports guests to a vibrant, sun-soaked cantina where the rhythmic press of fresh tortillas and the smoky aroma of roasted chilies fill the air. Diners gather around rustic tables to share plates bursting with the bright acidity of lime and the deep, earthy complexity of traditional moles, all paired with the crisp refreshment of hand-shaken margaritas. It is a soulful neighborhood gem that captures the festive energy of a Mexican plaza, turning every meal into a spirited celebration of bold flavors and warm hospitality.
• Bar Bruno — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Bar Bruno captures the sun-drenched spirit of a Mexico City bistro, where vibrant blue tiles and retro accents create a lively backdrop for spirited neighborhood gatherings. The air hums with the rhythm of cocktail shakers and the irresistible aroma of sizzling carnitas, inviting guests to linger over smoky mezcal margaritas and plates of zesty, street-style fare.
• Fatty Daddy — American · rated 4.2/5: Located in the heart of Boerum Hill, Fatty Daddy is a cozy Mexican eatery known for its comforting lunch and dinner offerings. Dive into delicious staples like tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and chicken burrito bowls, all served in an inviting atmosphere. Perfect for a quick bite or family dining, this spot is praised for its fresh ingredients and friendly service. Visit Fatty Daddy at 152 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY, and enjoy a satisfying meal that won't break the bank.
• The Royal Palms Shuffleboard Club — American · rated 4/5: Step into a vibrant, palm-fringed oasis where the rhythmic click of shuffleboard pucks mingles with a lively, retro-cool energy that feels like a permanent mid-century vacation. The air is scented with the irresistible aroma of golden truffle fries and warm, salt-dusted German pretzels, designed to be shared between frames alongside zesty street tacos and crisp, refreshing salads. It is a spirited social playground that marries nostalgic Florida charm with a modern, high-energy atmosphere, perfect for an evening of playful competition and indulgent comfort food.
• Bar Bruno — Mexican · rated 4/5: Sunlight streams through the expansive windows of this vibrant corner bistro, where the air is alive with the scent of charred chilies and the rhythmic clinking of salt-rimmed glasses. It is a neighborhood sanctuary that marries retro-cool aesthetics with the bright, zesty flavors of coastal Mexico, inviting guests to linger over crisp tacos and refreshing micheladas. Whether perched at the bustling bar or lounging on the breezy sidewalk, the experience is one of effortless conviviality and sun-drenched charm.
• White Maize — Mexican · rated 4/5: White Maize captures the vibrant spirit of Venezuelan street food, where the comforting aroma of golden, griddled cornmeal cakes fills the air. Each hand-held pocket is stuffed to bursting with savory treasures, from the rich, traditional layers of shredded beef and black beans to the bright, creamy indulgence of avocado-laced chicken salad. It is a lively destination where bold, rustic flavors and colorful ingredients come together to create a soulful dining experience that feels both deeply authentic and wonderfully welcoming.