Federici's Family Italian Restaurant – Italian
Steeped in a legacy of shared meals and laughter, this beloved neighborhood cornerstone invites guests into a warm, bustling space where the irresistible aroma of bubbling cheese and crisp, thin-crust pizza fills the air. Generations-old recipes come to life in every forkful of rich, slow-simmered marinara and hand-stretched dough, creating a timeless sanctuary of Italian comfort that feels like a seat at the family table.
14, East Main Street, NY +1-732-462-1312 https://www.federicis.com/Rating: 4.6/5 (1977 reviews)
Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $$
What diners are saying
Celebrated for its distinctive "bar pie" style pizza, diners rave about the ultra-thin, cracker-like crust that remains crispy and flavorful. Reviewers consistently highlight the satisfying balance of savory cheese and lively sauce, with the sausage pie and white pie with broccoli emerging as standout favorites. While one guest found the flavors mild, most describe the pizza as "perfection" and "binge-worthy," complemented by classic Italian dishes like Veal and Chicken Parmigiana. The atmosphere is noted as family-friendly and historic, though guests should be prepared to bring cash as cards
Restaurants near Federici's Family Italian Restaurant
- Round Pie — Italian
- Sal's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta — Italian
- Sal's Gourmet Pizza & Pasta — Italian
- Solo Bella Brick Oven Bistro — Italian
- Bonnetti's Restaurant and Pizzeria — Italian
- Bar Bella — Italian
- Mezza Luna — Italian
- Mezza Luna — Italian
- Jersey Freeze — American
- Rug Mill Deli & Convenience Store — American
- Charkol — Middle Eastern
- El Meson — Spanish
