Island Bagel Bar – American
Sunlight streams through the windows of this breezy morning retreat, where the intoxicating aroma of toasted seeds and freshly boiled dough fills the air. Hand-rolled bagels boast a perfect golden crust and a chewy, cloud-like center, serving as the canvas for velvety schmears and artisanal toppings that elevate the humble breakfast sandwich into a coastal-inspired feast.
272 Burnside Avenue +1-516-371-3357 https://food.orders.co/1z9jwrlm?y_source=1_MTA5NzgxMzY1MC03MTUtbG9jYXRpb24ud2Vic2l0ZQ%3D%3DRating: 3.9/5 (332 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $
What diners are saying
Diners have mixed but passionate feelings about this spot, with loyal fans raving about the delicious breakfast and lunch options, particularly the Nutella pancakes and avocado toast. While some guests appreciate the decent prices and standard bagel shop atmosphere, others express frustration with inconsistent service, citing long wait times and occasional staff inattentiveness. Despite service hiccups, the hot food and sandwiches remain a strong draw for many, making it a convenient stop for an early morning bite or a quick lunch.
Restaurants near Island Bagel Bar
- The Upper Crust — American
- Giant Bagel — American
- Sherwood Diner — American
- Traditions Eatery — American
- Barbacoa Artisanal Burger House — American
- Central Perk Cafe — American
- Mom's Pastries — American
- The Shoppe at Five Fifty — American
- Chickies Five Towns — American
- Toddy's — American
- Berrylicious Frozen Yogurt, Smoothies, Coffee and More — American
- Smash House — American
