Toddy's – American
Toddy’s captures the soulful essence of American comfort, where the warm glow of amber lighting meets the irresistible aroma of sizzling grills and slow-simmered classics. This lively neighborhood haunt invites guests to linger over generous plates and chilled glasses, offering a nostalgic yet vibrant atmosphere where every bite feels like a homecoming.
436 Central Avenue, Cedarhurst +1-516-295-1999 http://www.toddysbagels.com/Rating: 4.3/5 (88 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $$
Currently closed
What diners are saying
Celebrated as the best bagel shop in town, diners rave about the perfect texture of the bagels—crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Guests highlight the delicious fillings and sandwiches, specifically recommending the #3 whole wheat bagel stuffed with melted cheese, mushrooms, tomatoes, and jalapeños. While some mention mixed experiences with service, many praise the new ownership for creating an inviting, friendly atmosphere. Beyond the food, reviewers love the high-quality coffee available by the pound, with the vanilla and German blends standing out as must-try items.