Key Lime Pie Co. – American
Sun-drenched citrus notes and the buttery scent of toasted graham cracker crust fill this vibrant temple to Florida’s most iconic dessert. From velvety traditional slices to decadent chocolate-dipped bars, each creation balances a sharp, zesty tang with a smooth, creamy finish that captures the essence of the tropics in every bite. Guests can savor portable treats under the warm glow of a coastal afternoon or step behind the counter to master the art of the perfect tart filling in an interactive pie-making class.
Greene Street +13055176720 https://www.keylimepieco.comRating: 4/5 (1 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $$$
Dietary options: gluten-free, halal, vegetarian, low-sodium, pescatarian, anti-inflammatory
Diet fit at Key Lime Pie Co.
Gluten-Free at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 1 gluten-free-tagged dish on its current menu, including The Gluten Free Mini Pie!. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Halal at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 8 halal-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Key Lime Pie in a Cup, Sunrise Deal and Mini Key Lime Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Vegetarian at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 8 vegetarian-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Key Lime Pie in a Cup, Sunrise Deal and Mini Key Lime Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Low-Sodium at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 8 low-sodium-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Key Lime Pie in a Cup, Sunrise Deal and Mini Key Lime Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Pescatarian at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 8 pescatarian-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Key Lime Pie in a Cup, Sunrise Deal and Mini Key Lime Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Anti-Inflammatory at Key Lime Pie Co.
Key Lime Pie Co. in New York has 5 anti-inflammatory-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Key Lime Pie in a Cup, Mini Key Lime Pie and The Gluten Free Mini Pie!. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
How tags work: Dish-level menu analysis by Chefi's rule-based diet engine with AI assistance; nutrition values are estimated from ingredients unless marked verified. Allergen and certification claims are never inferred.
What to order at Key Lime Pie Co.
| Dish | Net carbs | Protein |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional Key Lime Pie | 56.2 g | 6.2 g |
Nutrition values are estimated from ingredients.
Currently closed
Hours
- Monday - Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
What diners are saying
Guests rave about the quality burgers and the intimate setting that creates a welcoming environment for couples and friends alike. Celebrated for its attentive service, reviewers highlight the helpful staff who ensure a seamless dining experience through regular check-ins. Standout dishes include the expertly prepared burgers, which are frequently praised for their high-quality ingredients and satisfying flavors.
Menu
Key Lime Pies
Our award-winning 100-year-old family recipe made with real key lime juice and all-natural ingredients.
- Traditional Key Lime Pie - $24.99: Handmade graham cracker crust, creamy tart key lime filling, homemade whipped cream topping. Nut-free. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium
- Mini Key Lime Pie - $8.95: Individual sized version of our traditional key lime pie with graham cracker crust and whipped topping. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory
- The Gluten Free Mini Pie! - $10.88: Gluten-free version of our signature mini key lime pie. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Gluten-Free, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory
Pie Bars & Cups
Unique ways to enjoy our signature key lime flavors.
- 12 Key Lime Pie Chocolate Dipped Bars - $46.99: Key lime pie slices on a popsicle stick, dipped in rich chocolate. Includes 12 bars. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium
- Key Lime Pie in a Cup - $8.95: 8-ounce cup with layers of key lime filling, graham cracker crust, and whipped cream. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory
Bundles & Deals
Special combinations of our most popular items.
- Sunrise Deal - $45.99: 1 Full Key Lime Pie and 6 Chocolate Dipped Bars. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium
- Sunset Key Deal - $62.99: 2 Key Lime Pies and 6 Key Lime Bars. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory
Experiences
Go behind the scenes and learn the art of pie making.
- Key Lime Pie Making Class - $45: Interactive class where you make your own mini key lime pie with graham cracker crust, filling, and topping. Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory
Frequently Asked Questions about Key Lime Pie Co.
- Is Key Lime Pie Co. gluten-free-friendly?
- Yes. Key Lime Pie Co. has 1 gluten-free-tagged dish on its current menu, including The Gluten Free Mini Pie!.
- What can I eat at Key Lime Pie Co. on a gluten-free diet?
- The Gluten Free Mini Pie! carry the gluten-free tag, out of 1 tagged dish on the current menu. Every dish's diet tags are listed in the menu.
- What is the highest-protein dish at Key Lime Pie Co.?
- Traditional Key Lime Pie, at roughly 6.2g of protein (estimated from ingredients).
Restaurants near Key Lime Pie Co.
- WILLIE T'S — American
- IRISH KEVIN'S BAR — American
- Margaritaville — American
- TWO FRIENDS PATIO RESTAURANT — American
- BAGATELLE RESTAURANT — American
- OLD TOWN TAVERN — American
- Pickles Pub's Sandbar — American
- Sloppy Joe's Bar — American
- Key Lime Pie Factory — American
- CELTIC CONCH PUBLIC HOUSE LLC — American
- Funky Rooster Coffee House & Wine Bar — American
- LITTLE WHITEHOUSE SUBS — American
