Rusty Nail Brooklyn – American
Stepping into Rusty Nail Brooklyn feels like discovering a hidden, amber-hued retreat where the clink of crystal and the scent of charred botanicals set a moody, cinematic tone. The bar masterfully balances the elemental and the ethereal, swirling together notes of smoldering woodsmoke and crisp alpine air into sophisticated sips that evoke the rugged beauty of the natural world. It is a sanctuary designed for slow evenings and deep conversation, where the warm glow of the lounge illuminates a world of bold flavors and artisanal craft.
1701 Foster Avenue, Brooklyn NY 11230 https://rustynailbrooklyn.com/Rating: 4/5 (1 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $
Currently open
Hours
- Monday - Thursday
- 3:00 PM - 11:00 PM
- Friday
- 3:00 PM - 12:00 AM
- Saturday
- 1:00 PM - 12:00 AM
- Sunday
- 1:00 PM - 11:00 PM
What diners are saying
Celebrated for perfectly cooked steaks and high-quality ingredients, guests consistently leave feeling satisfied by the flavorful menu. Reviewers highlight the intimate setting and knowledgeable staff who provide attentive service, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed yet refined meal. Standout dishes include the expertly prepared beef, which diners praise for its consistent quality and reasonable pricing.
Menu
- Rusty Nail - $14: Dewars blended Scotch, Drambuie, lemon oil
- Trapped In Amber - $14: Four Roses bourbon, Pear Nectar, orchard cordial, lemon
- Alpine Climb - $14: Granja Mezcal, apricot brandy, grapefruit, elderberry liqueur
- Siren Song - $14: Mount Gay rum, passionfruit puree, marachino liqueur, lime
- Woodsmoke - $14: Espolon Blanco tequila, ginger liqueur, luxardo marachino, basil
- Brushfire - $14: Rittenhouse rye, apple cider, bonal aperitif, pommegranate
- Sand Dollar - $14: Tanteo habanero tequila, pear nectar, apricot, lime
- Grey Dawn - $14: Four Roses bourbon, earl grey tea syrup, bitter orange, sweet vermouth
- Rusty Espresso Martini - $14: Titos vodka, Punt E Mes, Faretti espresso Liqueur, Brooklyn Roasting Cold Brew
- Riptide - $14: Granja Mezcal, amaretto, cinnamon, pommegranate, lime
- Frozen Margarita - $12: House made. Flavors: Strawberry, mango, or passionfruit
- House Hot Toddy - $12: Whiskey, cinnamon syrup, lemon
- Hot Apple Cider - $12: Fresh NY pressed hot cider, choice of liquor
- Lively Lodge - $13: Brandy, amaretto, vermouth, lemon
- Bold Return - $13: Granja Mezcal, ginger liqueur, lime
- Pitching Wedge - $8: Earl grey, rosemary, grenadine, lemon
- Below Deck - $8: Cinnamon, mango, lime, ginger
- Draft Beer - $8: Rotating seasonal selection
- Canned Beer - $7: Rotating seasonal selection
- Le Petit Champignon - Sparkling Brut - $11: N.V.
- M. Dean - Sauvignon Blanc - $12: 2022
- Berger - Gruner Veltliner - $12: 2023
- Isotta Manzoni - Sparkling Rose - $12: 2023
- Bieler Sabine - Rose - $12: 2024
- Charles and Charles - Cabernet Sauvignon - $12: 2021
- Bieler Pere et Fils - Cotes du Rhone - $12: 2020
- Yuengling Draft and Well Shot - $10: Combo special
- Bloody Mary - $9: Happy Hour Special
- Mimosa - $9: Happy Hour Special