Tanner Smith's – American
Stepping into this Midtown hideaway feels like discovering a well-kept secret, where the spirit of the Prohibition era lives on through vintage-inspired decor and a warm, amber-lit ambiance. The kitchen elevates American comfort through artfully plated dishes that pair perfectly with inventive craft cocktails, creating a sophisticated yet spirited retreat that captures the timeless allure of old New York.
204 West 55th Street, NY 10019 10019 646 https://tannersmiths.comRating: 4.4/5 (3257 reviews)
Cuisine: American
Price range: $$
What diners are saying
Celebrated for its vibrant speakeasy atmosphere and stunning vintage decor, guests rave about the unique "grandma’s house" aesthetic and lively local energy. Standout dishes include the melting waffles, truffle mac, and the highly recommended Birria Chimichanga, which reviewers describe as a flavorful must-order. Cocktail lovers praise the creative drink menu and bottomless mimosas, specifically highlighting the well-balanced Irish Bill. Visitors consistently highlight the attentive service and knowledgeable bartenders, noting that the space feels like an authentic escape in Midtown.