Best Affordable Burger in Herald Square | Top 11 Affordable Spots

11 restaurants in Best Affordable Burger in Herald Square | Top 11 Affordable Spots

• Black Iron Burger — American · rated 5/5: The air hums with the irresistible aroma of searing beef and the convivial clinking of glasses in this high-energy urban retreat. Thick, juicy patties are griddled to perfection and served alongside mountains of salt-dusted fries and shatteringly crisp onion rings, creating a bold feast that finds its perfect match in a frosty craft pint or a vibrant house cocktail.
• Olde City — American · rated 4.6/5: Olde City captures the spirit of a bustling neighborhood tavern where the aroma of seared beef and toasted rolls drifts through an inviting space of exposed brick and warm wood. It is a place where the clink of chilled pint glasses punctuates lively conversation, offering a soulful tribute to American classics through perfectly charred burgers and authentic, melt-in-your-mouth cheesesteaks.
• Bill's Bar & Burger — American · rated 4.3/5: The air hums with the savory aroma of searing beef and the cheerful clink of frosted beer mugs in this high-energy tavern, where the sizzle of the griddle sets a rhythmic tempo for a lively night out. Towering, juice-dripping burgers take center stage alongside golden piles of fries and decadent, hand-spun milkshakes that offer a nostalgic nod to the quintessential American diner. It is a soulful celebration of comfort food that captures the unpretentious joy of a classic backyard cookout elevated by a vibrant, urban pulse.
• The Counter — American · rated 4.3/5: This high-energy, modern eatery transforms the classic American burger into a personalized masterpiece, inviting guests to craft their own culinary journey amidst a sleek, industrial-chic backdrop. The air is thick with the savory aroma of sizzling patties and toasted buns, while an endless palette of artisanal toppings and creamy, hand-spun shakes ensures every visit is a fresh, flavor-packed adventure.
• Schnippers Quality Kitchen — American · rated 4.2/5: Schnippers brings the nostalgic charm of a classic American roadside stand into the heart of the city, where the rhythmic sizzle of the flat-top grill and the warm glow of neon create a vibrant, high-energy atmosphere. Golden-brown chicken and griddled burgers are served alongside thick, hand-spun milkshakes, offering a sensory celebration of comfort food crafted with elevated ingredients and a modern urban pulse. It is a bustling retreat where the satisfying crunch of a perfectly seasoned fry and the buttery warmth of a toasted bun provide a soulful escape from the surrounding city rush.
• Clinton Hall 36 — American · rated 4.2/5: Clinton Hall 36 pulses with the high-octane energy of a modern urban playground, where industrial-chic design and communal tables invite guests into a world of spirited games and lively social connection. The kitchen transforms American comfort into an indulgent experience, serving up towering, juice-dripping burgers and crispy fries that pair seamlessly with a rotating selection of rare craft brews flowing from their signature high-tech taps.
• Burgerology — American · rated 4.2/5: Step into a high-energy laboratory of flavor where the classic American burger is reimagined through a lens of culinary experimentation and bold, towering ingredients. The air hums with the sizzle of premium beef on the griddle, while neon accents and industrial-chic decor set the stage for indulgent creations and gravity-defying milkshakes that turn every meal into a decadent celebration.
• Grey Bar & Restaurant — American · rated 4/5: Grey Bar & Restaurant offers a sleek, contemporary escape where the vibrant colors of artisan salads meet the savory depth of perfectly seared proteins. Guests can linger over a delicate plate of ahi tuna or sink into a signature charred burger, all within an atmosphere that seamlessly blends urban sophistication with the comforting warmth of a neighborhood favorite.
• Schnippers Quality Kitchen — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant urban eatery reimagines the classic American roadside stand, where the nostalgic sizzle of the griddle and the aroma of searing beef fill a bright, bustling space. Diners tuck into an array of masterfully crafted burgers, from juice-dripping classics crowned with melted cheese to inventive plant-based creations, all served on toasted buns that capture the essence of elevated comfort food.
• 5 Napkin Burger — American: This high-energy urban tavern invites guests to roll up their sleeves and dive into a world of unapologetic indulgence, where the air is thick with the savory aroma of flame-grilled beef and golden, stacked onion rings. The kitchen masterfully balances messy, juice-dripping burgers with eclectic comforts like delicate tuna poke and soul-warming matzo ball soup, creating a vibrant atmosphere where every bite feels like a celebration of classic American cravings.
• Theatre Row Diner — American: This vibrant American eatery captures the high-energy spirit of the theater district, blending the nostalgic charm of a classic diner with a playful, modern edge. Sizzling 12oz smash burgers and golden breakfast staples share the spotlight with whimsical, towering "crazy shakes" and spirited shots, creating a lively stage for everything from midnight cravings to sun-drenched morning feasts.