Best Affordable Caribbean Restaurants in Little Italy | Affordable Caribbean Food

30 restaurants in Best Affordable Caribbean Restaurants in Little Italy | Affordable Caribbean Food

• Malaysia Beef Jerky Inc — Chinese · rated 5/5: The air around this bustling storefront is thick with the irresistible scent of caramelized honey and smoky charcoal, drawing passersby into a world of traditional Malaysian street flavors. Sheets of tender, hand-grilled jerky glisten under warm lights, offering a perfect balance of sweet glaze and savory spice that yields to a satisfying, smoky chew. This vibrant nook captures the soul of Southeast Asian night markets, where the rhythmic sizzle of the grill and rich, umami-packed aromas create a nostalgic haven for those seeking an authentic, handcrafted treat.
• Natural Blend — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Natural Blend is a laid-back vegan restaurant offering healthy and flavorful Caribbean delights for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. With a vibrant island vibe, customers can enjoy dishes like ackee and saltfish, jerk chicken, and a variety of sandwiches, salads, and soups. The cafe also serves fresh juices, smoothies, and coffee. Open daily, Natural Blend is perfect for nutritious meals on the go.
• Guyanese Treats — Indian · rated 4.7/5: Guyanese Treats in Elizabethport offers a cozy, casual setting perfect for lunch or dinner. Specializing in Caribbean comfort food, the menu features jerk chicken, curry chicken, roti, and fried sweet plantains. With options for takeout and curbside pickup, it's convenient for solo dining or family meals. Open Monday through Saturday, this small gem invites you to savor flavorful dishes in a relaxed atmosphere without breaking the bank.
• Natural Blend — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, Natural Blend offers a delightful mix of traditional Jamaican fare and vegetarian options, complemented by healthy smoothies, juices, and fresh coffee. With a cozy interior and a friendly atmosphere, this highly-rated spot is ideal for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Families are welcome, and there's plenty of seating. Credit cards and NFC payments are accepted.
• Pollo Campero — Spanish · rated 4.6/5: Located inside the Supremo Food Market in Elizabeth, Pollo Campero serves up flavorful fried and grilled chicken, complemented by a variety of sides and desserts. Open for brunch, lunch, dinner, and late-night bites, this fast-food chain offers a cozy atmosphere with quick and friendly service. With options like chicken wings, plantains, and horchata, plus vegetarian and gluten-free choices, there's something for everyone, including a kids' menu. Prices typically range from $10-$20.
• Yaadmandeli — Indian · rated 4.5/5: Discover Yaadmandeli, a gem in the Bronx offering delicious Jamaican cuisine with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Located at 943 Westchester Ave, this 24-hour restaurant has garnered a stellar 4.5 rating from happy patrons. Enjoy breakfast, lunch, dinner, or dessert with convenient curbside pickup and delivery options. Don't miss their signature jerk chicken and mouthwatering beef patties!
• Elsa La Reina Del Chicharron — Spanish · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in Washington Heights' vibrant Little Dominican Republic, Elsa La Reina Del Chicharron offers a laid-back dining experience with a focus on authentic Dominican comfort food. Try their standout dishes like chicharrón, mofongo, and fried plantains-all at an affordable price range of $10-20. Open daily from 10 AM to 9 PM, it's a casual spot that promises satisfying flavors in a cozy setting.
• Miss Lily's (Soho) — Jamaican · rated 4.3/5: Miss Lily's captures the electric spirit of a Kingston dancehall, wrapping guests in a kaleidoscope of neon lights, vintage vinyl, and the infectious rhythm of island beats. The kitchen breathes fire and soul into the air with the smoky heat of scotch bonnet peppers and the aromatic sweetness of pimento wood, creating a high-octane escape where every meal feels like a sun-drenched Caribbean celebration.
• Peppa's — American · rated 4.3/5: Peppa's is a laid-back eatery nestled in Flatbush's Little Caribbean and Little Haiti. Known for its stellar jerk chicken, this spot also serves up Jamaican favorites like curry goat, pepper shrimp, and festivals. Despite the typical wait, service is quick, and the food is perfect for both lunch and dinner. Located at 738 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, it's a must-try for fans of hearty Jamaican cuisine.
• Kopitiam — Restaurant · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of Chinatown, Kopitiam offers a laid-back dining experience with its cozy 25-seat space. This Malaysian cafe features a unique menu with hard-to-find dishes like nasi lemak, kaya toast, pan mee, and chicken jerky buns, complemented by a great selection of teas and traditional drinks. Open daily from 10 AM to 10 PM, Kopitiam delivers authentic flavors and a charming ambiance, making it a must-visit spot for food lovers.
• The Door — Caribbean · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in South Jamaica, The Door offers an inviting ambiance and a culinary journey through traditional Jamaican flavors. With a diverse menu ranging from flavorful jerk chicken to rich curry goat, there's something for every palate, including vegetarian options and a special kid's menu. Known for its friendly and professional staff, The Door is a go-to spot for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Popular among locals, the restaurant also features a welcoming bar, making it perfect for a cozy romantic evening or a family outing. Enjoy the rich tastes of Jamaica while basking in an upscale, yet cozy environment.
• El Castillo De Jagua Restaurant — Spanish · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in the heart of the Lower East Side, El Castillo De Jagua Restaurant is a long-standing gem offering a delightful mix of Spanish and Caribbean cuisine. Serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the menu's highlights include Cuban sandwiches, mofongo, and pernil, with ample vegetarian options. Popular for its satisfying portions and casual atmosphere, this spot promises fast service and friendly staff. Call +1 212-982-6412 for reservations.
• Peppa’s — Seafood · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 96 Stanton St, Peppa's offers an inviting casual atmosphere for families and food lovers alike. Specializing in classic Jamaican dishes like jerk chicken and mac 'n' cheese, this local gem has garnered a 4.1 rating from 169 reviews. Open daily from 2:00 PM, Peppa's is perfect for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite. Featuring a kid-friendly menu and various payment options, it's a must-visit spot for an authentic taste of Jamaica.
• Allan's Bakery — Caribbean · rated 4/5: The intoxicating aroma of spiced rum and toasted coconut drifts from this neighborhood gem, where golden loaves of Hardo bread and flaky turnovers bursting with tropical guava and mango line the shelves. Every bite of their signature Black Cake offers a rich, boozy journey through traditional flavors, while buttery currant rolls and dense coconut drops provide a comforting, sun-drenched taste of the islands.
• Fools Gold — American · rated 4/5: This high-energy social hub pulses with a rustic-industrial charm, where the aroma of warm Sigmund’s pretzels and sizzling shishito peppers draws a lively crowd. The kitchen reimagines classic comfort through an artisanal lens, pairing salty bespoke beef jerky and loaded Irish nachos with a vibrant atmosphere built for long nights and shared plates.
• Las Lap — Caribbean · rated 4/5: Las Lap pulses with the vibrant energy of the Caribbean, inviting guests into a spirited sanctuary where the air is thick with the aroma of island spices and the clinking of rum-filled glasses. Golden codfish fritters and jerk-spiced eggrolls offer a soulful journey through bold tropical flavors, perfectly complemented by botanical cocktails that evoke the warmth of a never-ending summer. Whether sharing a plate of crispy pholourie or diving into a comforting, crusty macaroni pie, every moment captures the essence of a sun-drenched celebration.
• Sam's — American · rated 4/5: **About Sam's:** Nestled in the heart of the West Bronx, Sam's offers a relaxed lounge setting with delicious Southern comfort food. Popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the menu features favorites like jerk chicken, fried fish, and macaroni and cheese, complemented by a full bar serving cocktails, beer, and wine. With live music, dancing, and karaoke, Sam's is perfect for solo diners and groups looking to enjoy good food and entertainment.
• PJ — American · rated 4/5: PJ's in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, is a casual eatery that brings the flavors of the Caribbean to your table. Specializing in staples like rice and peas, curry chicken, and stew beef, this spot offers a variety of well-seasoned dishes, including their highly recommended jerk chicken with rice and peas. Open daily and offering takeout and delivery, PJ's is a convenient and delicious choice for Caribbean fare.
• Dominican Cravings — Spanish · rated 4/5: Nestled in the bustling Essex Market, Dominican Cravings brings the vibrant flavors of the Caribbean to New York City. With a 4-star rating from 44 reviews, this gem serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, offering a variety of traditional Dominican dishes, including their famous empanadas. The restaurant boasts outdoor seating and a welcoming ambiance, perfect for families. With convenient service options like dine-in, takeout, and delivery, and accepting credit, debit, and NFC payments, Dominican Cravings promises a delightful culinary experience. Whether you're a local or a visitor, come savor the taste of the Caribbean at 76 Essex Street.
• Peppa's — American · rated 4/5: Peppa's is a laid-back eatery located at 689 Utica Ave, Brooklyn. Specializing in Jamaican comfort classics like jerk chicken and oxtail, this spot offers an authentic taste that's reminiscent of Jamaica. Known for its fresh flavors and consistent quality, Peppa's is a popular choice, with over 1200 user ratings. The restaurant serves beer, provides takeout options, and features free street parking for added convenience.
• Chris — American · rated 3.8/5: Nestled in Brooklyn at 613 Nostrand Ave, Chris serves up a satisfying array of Jamaican comfort food. Enjoy favorites like rotis and jerk chicken in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere. Notable for its hearty meals and welcoming staff, this spot is perfect for filling your soul and stomach. Open daily from early morning till late night, it's an ideal destination for both dine-in and takeout options.
• Siu's — Chinese · rated 3.8/5: Nestled in East Flatbush, Little Caribbean, Siu's is a laid-back Chinese eatery that specializes in comfort food. With popular dishes like chicken wings, fried rice, and beef lo mein, this spot is perfect for quick bites and late-night cravings. Vegetarian options and delivery are also available. Affordable pricing ($10-20 per meal) and a cash-only policy make it a go-to for locals.
• Yardie — Caribbean · rated 3.8/5: Nestled on Liberty Ave in Brooklyn, Yardie offers a taste of authentic Jamaican cuisine. Open from Monday to Saturday, this family-friendly restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, focusing on delicious Jamaican dishes. While outdoor seating isn't available, Yardie provides takeout, making it a convenient choice for a satisfying meal. With a user rating of 3.8 stars, Yardie invites you to explore its Caribbean flavors.
• Peppa’s — American · rated 3.8/5: Nestled in the heart of Canarsie, Peppa’s offers a laid-back atmosphere with a focus on Caribbean comfort food. Known for its flavorful jerk chicken, mac and cheese, and rice and peas, this casual eatery serves quick bites and late-night fare for lunch and dinner. With the convenience of delivery and moderate pricing, typically between $10-$20, Peppa’s is a beloved spot for delicious, authentic Caribbean cuisine.
• Linda's — American · rated 3.7/5: Linda's, located at 5322 Church Ave in Brooklyn's East Flatbush, is a beloved Caribbean spot known for its comfort food. Open daily, this casual counter-serve venue offers a menu full of favorites like roti, black pudding, beef patties, and cheese rolls, along with coffee and desserts. Popular among locals, it’s perfect for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Dine-in or takeout, Linda's has you covered.
• Footprints Cafe — Seafood · rated 3.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Coney Island, Footprints Cafe is a laid-back Jamaican restaurant offering a cozy atmosphere and tantalizing traditional Caribbean fare. From the famous Rasta Pasta to mouth-watering jerk chicken, guests are treated to a variety of options, including vegetarian and vegan dishes. Ideal for families and group celebrations, the café also features live music, happy hour specials, and fast service. Reserve a table to ensure a memorable dining experience!
• Irie — Caribbean · rated 3.3/5: Nestled in Crown Heights, Irie offers a laid-back dining experience with an array of classic Jamaican and Caribbean dishes. Known for its jerk chicken, curry goat, and vegetarian options, this cozy spot is perfect for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. With a family-friendly atmosphere and a range of healthy choices, Irie also provides coffee, desserts, late-night bites, and delivery services. Reservations available.
• Excell's Kingston Eatery — American · rated 3/5: Located at 76 Varick St, New York, Excell's Kingston Eatery offers a delightful dining experience featuring lunch, dinner, and irresistible desserts. With child-friendly amenities and wheelchair accessibility, it welcomes everyone. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM, the eatery accepts both cash and credit cards. While a reviewer highly praised their jerk chicken and pork tenderloins, it’s also known for takeout options.
• Miss Lily's (Soho) — Caribbean: This vibrant Soho escape pulses with the energy of a Jamaican island party, where checkered floors and vintage record covers create a retro-cool backdrop for soulful Caribbean dining. The air is thick with the smoky, intoxicating scent of jerk spices and scotch bonnet peppers, drawing guests into a sun-drenched world of fiery grilled meats, creamy coconut curries, and tropical cocktails that taste like a permanent vacation.
• Dominican Cravings — Spanish: Sun-drenched flavors and the rhythmic energy of the Caribbean come alive in this vibrant space, where the savory scent of slow-roasted pernil and garlic-infused plantains fills the air. Each plate is a soulful celebration of Dominican heritage, offering comforting textures of golden-fried tostones and rich, simmered stews that transport diners to the heart of a bustling Santo Domingo kitchen.