Best Burger in Gramercy | Top 4 Spots

11 restaurants in Best Burger in Gramercy | Top 4 Spots

• The Winslow — British · rated 5/5: The Winslow pulses with the spirited energy of a modern public house, where the aroma of bubbling jalapeño mac and cheese and golden-fried pickles invites guests into a lively, communal atmosphere. The kitchen masterfully bridges continents, pairing the traditional crunch of perfectly golden fish and chips with the bold, spicy glaze of gochujang duck wings and savory Scotch eggs. Whether settling in for a towering signature burger or a hearty pork belly BLT, diners find a vibrant sanctuary where elevated comfort food and neighborhood charm collide.
• Olde City — American · rated 4.6/5: Olde City captures the spirit of a bustling neighborhood tavern where the aroma of seared beef and toasted rolls drifts through an inviting space of exposed brick and warm wood. It is a place where the clink of chilled pint glasses punctuates lively conversation, offering a soulful tribute to American classics through perfectly charred burgers and authentic, melt-in-your-mouth cheesesteaks.
• Joe Junior — American · rated 4.5/5: Step into a timeless slice of Manhattan nostalgia where the rhythmic sizzle of the griddle and the comforting clatter of heavy ceramic mugs define the neighborhood's heartbeat. Golden-brown burgers and velvety, hand-spun milkshakes are served across a polished Formica counter, offering a soulful retreat where the warm glow of neon and the snug embrace of a vinyl booth celebrate the enduring charm of the classic American diner.
• Cozy Soup 'n' Burger — American · rated 4.2/5: This quintessential Greenwich Village landmark invites diners into a world of nostalgic comfort, where the hum of conversation mingles with the savory aroma of searing beef and slow-simmered broths. Deep vinyl booths and the warm glow of neon set the stage for soul-warming bowls of split pea soup and towering, juice-dripping burgers that anchor the neighborhood’s spirit. It is a timeless sanctuary
• Orion Diner & Grill — American · rated 4.1/5: Bathed in the nostalgic glow of neon and the gleam of polished chrome, this quintessential American diner serves as a warm sanctuary where the aroma of fresh-brewed coffee and sizzling griddles fills the air. From golden stacks of buttermilk pancakes dripping with syrup to the savory char of a perfectly seared burger, every plate captures the soulful essence of classic comfort within the cozy embrace of timeless vinyl booths.
• Grey Bar & Restaurant — American · rated 4/5: Grey Bar & Restaurant offers a sleek, contemporary escape where the vibrant colors of artisan salads meet the savory depth of perfectly seared proteins. Guests can linger over a delicate plate of ahi tuna or sink into a signature charred burger, all within an atmosphere that seamlessly blends urban sophistication with the comforting warmth of a neighborhood favorite.
• The Broken Shaker — Middle Eastern · rated 3/5: This vibrant social sanctuary pulses with an eclectic, laid-back energy, inviting guests to unwind amidst a tapestry of bold, globally-inspired flavors. The kitchen turns out a playful array of shareable bites, from the bright acidity of shrimp ceviche and spicy tuna crispy rice to the rich, nutty depth of brown butter hummus and salt-dusted Bavarian pretzels. It is a spirited retreat where juice-dripping burgers and crispy tacos are served in a convivial atmosphere, making every visit feel like a celebrated escape.
• Motel No Tell — American · rated 3/5: This playful, retro-inspired haunt captures the spirit of a sun-soaked getaway, inviting guests to lounge in a space where nostalgic charm meets a vibrant, laid-back energy. Crisp margherita pizzas and classic, juice-dripping burgers pair effortlessly with frosty poolside cocktails and ice-cold beers, perfect for long afternoons that stretch into neon-lit evenings. Whether sharing a spread of vibrant small plates or cooling off with a salt-rimmed margarita, every moment feels like a permanent vacation from the everyday.
• Hill and Bay — American: Hill and Bay serves as a vibrant neighborhood anchor where the rustic charm of a classic grill house meets the refined, sun-drenched flavors of a coastal bistro. The air is thick with the savory aroma of flame-seared burgers stacked with gourmet flair, while elegant plates of chimichurri-drizzled steak and Thai-glazed salmon offer a sophisticated global journey for the palate. It is a welcoming retreat that balances casual, high-energy comfort with a commitment to bold, artisanal ingredients.
• The Grey Dog — American (Burgers, sandwiches, breakfast: This bustling neighborhood gem hums with a welcoming energy, drawing guests in with the comforting aroma of griddled pancakes and savory chorizo hash. The kitchen transforms morning staples into soulful feasts, from the golden crunch of fried chicken atop sweet johnny cakes to vibrant plates of chilaquiles and buttery, flake-filled croissants. It is a sun-drenched sanctuary where the clink of coffee mugs and the indulgence of salted caramel pancakes create the quintessential backdrop for a leisurely, heartfelt meal.
• Xi'an Famous Foods — Chinese: The air hums with the rhythmic thwack of dough hitting the counter as chefs pull wide, ribbon-like noodles by hand, drenching them in a signature blend of tingly Sichuan peppercorns and aromatic chili oil. Crusty, spice-rubbed burgers and slippery "cold-skin" noodles provide a vibrant counterpoint to the bold, cumin-heavy heat that defines this high-energy tribute to Shaanxi street food.