Best Fine Dining Italian Restaurants in Herald Square | Fine Dining Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Fine Dining Italian Restaurants in Herald Square | Fine Dining Italian Food

• Angelina Bakery Nomad — Italian · rated 5/5: Sunlight dances across the sleek counters of this vibrant NoMad gem, where the air is thick with the sweet perfume of yeast and caramelized sugar. Artisanal bakers showcase their craft in an open kitchen, turning out cloud-like bomboloni and golden, multi-layered pastries that offer a decadent escape from the bustling city streets. It is a stylish sanctuary of Italian indulgence, inviting guests to savor every buttery bite alongside a perfectly pulled espresso in a bright, modern setting.
• La Stanza — Italian · rated 5/5: La Stanza, located at 536 Forest Ave, Staten Island, is a delightful Italian restaurant perfect for families, offering a variety of dining options including lunch, dinner, takeout, and delivery. Guests can enjoy coffee and dessert in a wheelchair-accessible environment. With curbside pickup available and generous operating hours, La Stanza ensures a convenient and enjoyable dining experience for all. For more information, visit [lastanzasi.com](http://lastanzasi.com/) or call +1 718-568-7547.
• David’s Pasta Palace — efc847f5-a649-46cb-8f81-9d9133e5255a · rated 5/5: David’s Pasta Palace, nestled at 1647 E 15th St, Brooklyn, NY 11229, offers a delightful blend of traditional and contemporary Italian cuisine. Renowned for its cozy, apartment-inspired ambiance, this restaurant highlights the creativity and passion of Chef Davido. With a range of meticulously crafted dishes and a reputation for outstanding service, it’s an exceptional dining destination in Brooklyn.
• Punto A — Italian · rated 5/5: Punto A, located at 83 Livingston St, Elizabeth, NJ 07206, is praised for its delicious food and vibrant wall designs. With a perfect 5-star rating from patrons, it’s a must-visit spot in Elizabeth. The new owner is renowned for being exceptionally kind and approachable. Though temporarily closed, Punto A eagerly awaits to welcome back its guests for dine-in and takeout experiences.
• AperiBar — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Nestled in Midtown Manhattan's Theater District, AperiBar offers a cozy, romantic atmosphere perfect for breakfast, dinner, and happy hour. Featuring artisanal pizzas, pastas, shared plates, and exquisite desserts like saffron honey gelato, the menu is complemented by a fine selection of beer, wine, and cocktails. With outstanding service and a welcoming ambiance, AperiBar is an ideal destination for a delightful culinary experience.
• Pronto Pasta & More — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Steaming bowls of al dente pasta take center stage at this lively Italian haunt, where the air carries the savory perfume of sautéed garlic and bright, garden-fresh basil. From silky ribbons of fettuccine bathed in rich cream to rustic, slow-simmered red sauces, every dish captures the soulful warmth of a traditional kitchen while maintaining a vibrant, modern energy perfect for a spirited meal with friends.
• ANDIAMO PIZZA — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 115 E 23rd St, ANDIAMO PIZZA is a casual eatery celebrated for its diverse menu that includes pizzas with a variety of toppings, wings, salads, pastas, and sandwiches. With a family-friendly atmosphere and a stellar 4.8 rating from 590 reviews, it's perfect for both a quick bite and a leisurely meal. Open until late, ANDIAMO PIZZA also offers delivery, takeout, free parking, and an array of drink options, including wine and beer.
• Lexington Famous Pizza — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Discover Lexington Famous Pizza, a culinary gem in the heart of New York at 50 Lexington Ave. Boasting a stellar 4.8 rating from 39 reviews, this halal pizzeria delights with mouthwatering slices, including crowd-favorite beef pepperoni. Open from 9 AM daily, it's perfect for lunch or a late-night bite. Enjoy the convenience of curbside pickup, takeout, and various payment options. Highly recommended!
• TONDA Pizza — Italian · rated 4.8/5: TONDA Pizza is a casual eatery in New York serving individual 6-inch pizzas and traditional Italian flatbreads. With a 4.8-star rating and glowing reviews highlighting fresh ingredients and fast service, it's a local favorite. Ideal for families and sports enthusiasts, the restaurant offers lunch, dinner, dessert, and outdoor seating. Located at 1231 Broadway, it accepts various payment options and provides both dine-in and takeout services.
• Crema Gourmet Espresso Bar — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled at 3 E 40th St, New York, Crema Gourmet Espresso Bar is a delightful breakfast spot blending modern charm with a cozy ambiance. With a stellar 4.8 rating from 86 reviews, it’s perfect for brunch enthusiasts and coffee lovers. Serving a diverse menu, including healthy options and delectable desserts, this café ensures a memorable dining experience with exceptional service and a prime location near Bryant Park.
• Villa Berulia — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into this Murray Hill sanctuary feels like a journey to a more graceful era, where white-tablecloth elegance and soft candlelight create an atmosphere of timeless intimacy. The kitchen breathes life into the heart of the Mediterranean, filling the air with the enticing aromas of garlic-infused seafood and rich, velvety sauces that cling to perfectly al dente pasta. It is a place where every meal feels like a celebration, inviting diners to slow down and savor soulful Italian flavors amidst the sophisticated charm of a classic New York dining room.
• Reilly's Plates & Pours — American · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of New York, Reilly's Plates & Pours offers a delightful mix of comfort food, blending pizza and sushi with refreshing beer, wine, and cocktails. With a stellar 4.7 rating from 197 reviews, it's a great spot to catch a game or enjoy the outdoor seating. Open from early morning until late night, it ensures a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Visit for an exceptional dining experience!
• Vito's Slices and Ices — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 464 9th Ave, New York, Vito's Slices and Ices is an inviting spot celebrated for its delicious New York-style pizza and authentic atmosphere. With a stellar 4.7 rating from over 1,300 reviews, this pizza restaurant is a neighborhood favorite. Known for its friendly service and mouth-watering slices, Vito’s also features outdoor seating and refreshing Italian Ice. Open daily, it's a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.
• Whole Foods NoMad Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 63 Madison Ave, New York, Whole Foods NoMad Pizza boasts a reputation for its clean, well-organized space and friendly atmosphere. Renowned for its NY-style pizza, the restaurant also offers a variety of hot and cold foods, along with desserts and coffee. With a stellar 4.7-star rating, the venue caters well to families and offers convenient payment options. Enjoy dine-in, takeout, or delivery services every day from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM.
• Lulla — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled in the heart of Chelsea, Lulla is a family-friendly gem offering a delightful blend of Italian comfort food and top-notch hospitality. Located at 113 W 24th St, the restaurant boasts a cozy ambiance with live music, outdoor seating, and a versatile menu suitable for all ages. With a 4.7-star rating from 70 reviews, Lulla is known for its exceptional service, delectable dishes, and inviting atmosphere. Reservations are welcomed, making it a perfect spot for any occasion. Enjoy breakfast, lunch, dinner, and a variety of drinks, including wine and cocktails, in this accessible and vibrant eatery.
• Square pizza NYC Time Square — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Welcome to Square Pizza NYC Times Square, your go-to spot for delicious New York-style pizza in Midtown South’s Garment District. Known for its flavorful slices and generous portions, this casual eatery serves up a variety of toppings on both round and square pies. The relaxed atmosphere is perfect for families, and the staff is always helpful. Open daily from 11:00 AM to late, you can enjoy a quick bite or takeout at reasonable prices. Visit us at 316 W 39th St, New York, or call +1 646-596-7070 for more info.
• Traditas Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Traditas Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria located at 83 Maiden Ln, New York. They offer a wide array of classic slices, heros, pastas, salads, and Italian ices. With a rating of 4.7 and over 200 user reviews, it is especially praised for its delicious pizza and friendly service. Open from Monday to Saturday, Traditas Pizza is known for its welcoming atmosphere, making it perfect for family visits. Delivery and curbside pickup options are available.
• ANDIAMO PIZZA — Italian · rated 4.7/5: **About Andiamo Pizza** Discover the taste of traditional NYC-style pizza at Andiamo Pizza, located at 818 6th Ave, New York. With a stellar 4.7 rating and 829 user reviews, this family-operated eatery serves up a variety of slices, pies, calzones, rolls, salads, and more. Ideal for families, Andiamo Pizza offers a kid-friendly menu, as well as dessert, coffee, beer, and wine. Open late seven days a week!
• Pasta Fina NYC — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Nestled at 635 2nd Ave in New York, Pasta Fina NYC delights with its exceptional Italian cuisine. With a stellar 4.7 rating, it’s clear why this spot has captured the hearts of many. Boasting a kid-friendly atmosphere and diverse menu, it welcomes diners for lunch and dinner, offering both dine-in and delivery options. Convenient payment methods and accessibility ensure a seamless dining experience. Reach out at +1 646-707-3500.
• Traditas Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 1165 Broadway Store 7 in New York, Traditas Pizza offers a delightful assortment of slices, pies, pasta, and heroes. Boasting a user rating of 4.7 with over 269 reviews, this family-friendly pizzeria also features children’s options on the menu. Open daily, Traditas Pizza provides takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery services, making it the perfect choice for a quick, delicious meal.
• NY Pizza Suprema — Italian · rated 4.6/5: The air at Pizza Suprema is thick with the comforting aroma of toasted flour and bubbling mozzarella, drawing guests into a space where the rhythmic toss of dough serves as a prelude to a masterfully crafted meal. Each hand-stretched pie emerges from the oven with a blistered, golden crust that offers a satisfying crunch, perfectly balancing the bright acidity of sun-ripened tomatoes and the creamy richness of melted cheeses. This vibrant sanctuary hums with the timeless energy of an authentic Italian kitchen, where the simple alchemy of fire and flour creates an experience that is both bustling and deeply nostalgic.
• Tony's — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Tony’s captures the timeless soul of an Italian kitchen, where the intoxicating scent of slow-simmered ragu and toasted garlic drifts through a dining room bathed in the warm, golden glow of candlelight. Guests find sanctuary in a space that feels like a shared secret, lingering over silken ribbons of handmade pasta and robust glasses of Chianti while the rhythmic clinking of wine glasses creates a melody of celebration and comfort.
• Capizzi — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into this cozy retreat feels like a journey to a rustic Italian kitchen, where the amber glow of a wood-fired oven illuminates vintage decor and the air carries the irresistible perfume of bubbling mozzarella and fresh herbs. Hand-stretched pizzas arrive with a signature leopard-spotted char, offering a crisp yet chewy canvas for vibrant sauces and artisanal toppings that honor traditional craftsmanship. It is a soulful sanctuary where the warmth of a family gathering meets the sophisticated simplicity of authentic Mediterranean flavors.
• Nizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nizza transports diners to the sun-drenched shores of the Italian Riviera, where the lively hum of conversation mingles with the irresistible aroma of golden, herb-crusted socca and slow-simmered ragus. The kitchen celebrates the bright, coastal flavors of the Mediterranean through silken handmade pastas and vibrant seasonal plates, all served in a breezy space that radiates warmth and effortless European charm.
• Il Punto Ristorante — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Il Punto Ristorante feels like entering a refined Italian villa where the soft clink of wine glasses and the warm glow of amber lighting set the stage for an intimate evening. The kitchen transforms seasonal ingredients into poetic plates of silken handmade pasta and tender braised meats, each bite a harmonious balance of rustic tradition and modern elegance. It is a place where time slows down over lingering pours of Chianti and the comforting embrace of authentic flavors, capturing the true spirit of Mediterranean hospitality.
• Gallo Nero — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Stepping into Gallo Nero feels like finding a hidden corner of Tuscany, where the air is thick with the intoxicating aroma of slow-simmered ragu and guests linger over glasses of deep crimson Chianti. The rustic, candlelit space hums with the convivial energy of a shared family feast, inviting diners to slow down and savor the warmth of traditional hospitality. Every plate celebrates the soul of the Italian countryside, pairing the delicate, silken texture of hand-rolled pasta with the robust, earthy flavors of time-honored recipes.
• Mangia — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Mangia captures the spirited essence of a bustling Italian kitchen, where the air is thick with the fragrance of simmering pomodoro and the convivial hum of friends gathered over overflowing plates. Hand-crafted pastas and sun-ripened ingredients bring a taste of the Mediterranean to life, offering a warm, rustic sanctuary where every meal feels like a celebration of family and tradition.
• Tony's Di Napoli — italian_restaurant · rated 4.6/5
• Lupetto — efc847f5-a649-46cb-8f81-9d9133e5255a · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the heart of New York's Flatiron District, Lupetto is a wood-fired Italian steakhouse that delights with housemade pasta, Neapolitan-style pizzas, and quality steaks. The open kitchen and cozy, trendy ambiance make for an inviting dining experience. With a craft cocktail program and extensive wine list, it's a perfect spot for a memorable meal. Reservations are recommended.
• Roma Pizza & restaurant — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Welcome to Roma Pizza & Restaurant, a family-owned gem in Midtown Manhattan at 980 6th Ave. Enjoy delicious comfort food, from diverse pizza slices like pepperoni and chicken bacon ranch to hearty pasta, subs, and salads. With a casual, kid-friendly atmosphere and options for dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery, Roma Pizza promises great service and unforgettable flavors. Open daily.