Best Italian Restaurants in Upper West Side | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Upper West Side | Top Rated Italian Food

• Due fratelli w. — Italian · rated 4.9/5: Nestled in the heart of Jamaica, NY, Due Fratelli W. has quickly become a local favorite, boasting a remarkable 4.9-star rating from 28 reviews. Open daily from 10 AM (11 AM on Sundays) to 10 PM, this cozy pizza haven offers a family-friendly atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Known for its delectable pizza and top-notch service, Due Fratelli W. accepts credit cards, provides takeout, and offers delivery. Don't miss out on this gem!
• Celeste — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Celeste invites guests into a luminous sanctuary where the rustic charm of the Italian countryside meets a refined, modern elegance. Silk-smooth ribbons of pasta are hand-crafted daily and paired with sun-ripened tomatoes and fragrant oils, creating a sensory tapestry that honors the soul of Mediterranean cooking. It is a place where time slows down over bottles of bold Nebbiolo, turning every meal into a vibrant celebration of flavor and heritage.
• Lucciola — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Bathed in a warm, amber glow that mimics the flicker of fireflies, this intimate sanctuary invites guests to linger over tables draped in white linen and adorned with sparkling crystal. The kitchen breathes life into the traditions of Emilia-Romagna, where the earthy aroma of shaved truffles meets the rich, velvety textures of hand-rolled pasta and slow-simmered sauces. It is a place where time slows down, allowing the marriage of vintage Italian wines and soulful, artfully plated dishes to create a truly romantic escape.
• Mimi's Pizza (Broadway) — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled at 2393 Broadway in New York, Mimi's Pizza (Broadway) has quickly become a beloved spot for pizza aficionados on the Upper West Side. Esteemed for its delicious pepperoni squares and an extensive variety of flavors, this family-friendly restaurant boasts a 4.8-star rating from 83 reviews. Mimi's offers dine-in, takeout, curbside pickup, and delivery, making it a convenient choice for any occasion. Open daily from 10 AM to 10 PM, it's the perfect place to enjoy fresh, tasty slices in a welcoming atmosphere.
• My Pie Pizzeria Romana — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Step into a slice of Rome where the rhythmic sound of shears cutting through crisp, airy crust mingles with the enticing aroma of herb-infused oils and San Marzano tomatoes. Long, rectangular trays showcase a vibrant tapestry of artisanal toppings resting atop a signature dough that shatters with a satisfying crunch, inviting diners to explore a rotating gallery of bold, seasonal flavors. This bustling space captures the effortless charm of an Italian piazza, offering a sensory escape that celebrates the authentic spirit of Roman street food.
• Song'e Napule — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into this vibrant slice of Naples, guests are greeted by the intoxicating scent of charred dough and sweet San Marzano tomatoes wafting from a roaring wood-fired oven. The space pulses with a spirited, soulful energy where soccer memorabilia and rustic charm set the stage for pillowy, leopard-spotted pizzas that transport the palate straight to the bustling streets of Italy.
• Sempre Oggi — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Sempre Oggi captures the fleeting beauty of the seasons within a luminous, modern space that pulses with the warmth of spirited Italian hospitality. Here, the kitchen transforms peak-harvest ingredients into vibrant, hand-crafted pastas and coastal-inspired plates that celebrate the simple joy of the present moment. It is a soulful retreat where timeless Old World traditions are reimagined with a fresh, contemporary energy, inviting guests to linger over every sun-kissed bite.
• Osteria Accademia — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Tucked away like a scholarly sanctuary, this intimate retreat surrounds diners with floor-to-ceiling bookshelves and the comforting aroma of slow-simmered ragus and toasted garlic. It is a place where intellectual charm meets rustic elegance, offering a warm space to savor silken, hand-rolled pastas and robust regional wines that celebrate the soulful traditions of Italy.
• Village Square Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Stepping into this lively neighborhood hub, guests are greeted by the rhythmic toss of fresh dough and the intoxicating aroma of garlic-infused oil sizzling in the oven. Golden, thin-crust pies emerge with perfectly blistered edges and vibrant toppings, offering a soulful taste of Italian tradition that transforms a simple meal into a warm, communal celebration.
• Spiga Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Located at 57 W 84th St, New York, Spiga Restaurant is a cozy gem offering classic Italian dishes, wine, and desserts in a romantic setting. With a 4.7-star rating based on 202 reviews, it's a favorite spot for a delightful dining experience. Enjoy fresh pasta, a well-curated wine list, and delicious desserts. Perfect for date night or a gathering with friends, reservations are recommended to secure your spot.
• Noi Due — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Bathed in the warm glow of amber lights, this intimate haven captures the soulful essence of a Roman trattoria through the intoxicating aromas of toasted garlic and bubbling mozzarella. Hand-rolled pastas and vibrant, seasonal ingredients take center stage, creating a convivial atmosphere where every shared plate feels like a celebration of authentic Italian heritage.
• Made in New York Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: This high-energy slice shop captures the electric pulse of Manhattan, where the intoxicating scent of bubbling mozzarella and blistered dough invites diners into a world of bold, urban flavor. Each oversized slice boasts a thin, crisp foundation that yields with a satisfying crackle, topped with a bright, zesty sauce and a molten layer of premium cheese. It is a quintessential sanctuary for the New York fold, where artisanal craft meets the timeless, fast-paced spirit of the city.
• Noi Due Cafe — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Noi Due Cafe is a kosher Italian restaurant renowned for its diverse menu that features pizza, pasta, and delightful brunch options. With its cozy, romantic ambiance and attentive service, it's a favorite for both lunch and dinner. Popular dishes include mac and cheese balls, baked ziti, and a variety of desserts like creme brulee and cheesecake. Reservations recommended.
• Parla — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Parla offers a delightful dining experience with its New York-style pizza and Italian-inspired cocktails. The menu features unique pizzas like the hot honey margarita and clam pie, alongside classics such as meatballs and burrata. Popular for both lunch and dinner, Parla is a hit with families and offers fast, friendly service. With a rating of 4.6 stars from 136 reviews, it's a recommended spot for great pizza and drinks.
• Song’e Napule Upper West — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled on Amsterdam Ave in New York, Song'E Napule Upper West serves up Neapolitan pizza, pasta, and classic Italian fare in a stylish, cozy atmosphere. With a full bar, outdoor seating, and options for curbside pickup and delivery, this spot is perfect for family outings or a delightful dinner with friends. Rated 4.6 by 261 reviewers, it's a must-visit for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
• Salumeria Rosi — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This intimate Tuscan-inspired gem transports diners to a bustling Roman deli, where shelves overflow with artisanal oils and the air carries the irresistible aroma of freshly sliced salumi. Guests linger over marble tables, sharing vibrant small plates and expertly curated meat boards that celebrate the bold, rustic flavors of Italy’s countryside. Every glass of wine and bite of aged cheese feels like a curated invitation to slow down and savor the soulful art of the Italian table.
• Tarallucci e Vino — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Sunlight streams through the windows of this rustic-chic retreat, where the morning hum of an Italian espresso bar evolves into an intimate evening of candlelit dining and regional wine pairings. The kitchen honors tradition with silken handmade pastas and vibrant seasonal plates, creating a soulful atmosphere where every meal feels like a leisurely escape to the heart of the Mediterranean.
• Bellini — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Bathed in a warm, golden glow, Bellini captures the effortless glamour of a Venetian palazzo where the air is thick with the aroma of toasted garlic and simmering ragu. Silken ribbons of handmade pasta and vibrant, seasonal antipasti celebrate the soul of Italian tradition, inviting guests to linger over sparkling cocktails in a space that feels both intimately romantic and grandly celebratory.
• Marinara Pizza — Italian · rated 4.5/5: The intoxicating aroma of garlic-infused oil and slow-simmered San Marzano tomatoes drifts through the air at this vibrant neighborhood haunt, where the rhythmic toss of dough sets the stage for a true Italian feast. Each blistered, thin-crust masterpiece arrives at the table draped in molten cheese and garden-fresh herbs, inviting diners to linger over a slice in a space that hums with the soulful warmth of a shared family meal.
• Carmine's — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Nestled on Graham Avenue in Brooklyn, Carmine's offers a delightful blend of wood-fired pizzas, classic Italian entrees, and refreshing cocktails. With a cozy, sports-centric ambiance and outdoor seating, it's an excellent spot for both family outings and catching the game with friends. Rated 4.5 stars by over 1,400 guests, this casual eatery also features kid-friendly options, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether for dine-in, takeout, or delivery, Carmine's promises generous portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
• Cibo e Vino — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Cibo e Vino, a charming Italian restaurant and wine bar on the Upper West Side, offers a seasonal menu featuring popular dishes like tagliatelle Bolognese and penne alla vodka, as well as options for vegetarians and kids. Enjoy a cozy, romantic ambiance with attentive service, delectable desserts, and a diverse drinks menu. Perfect for brunch, dinner, or special celebrations, Cibo e Vino ensures a delightful dining experience.
• Carmine's — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Carmine's is a delightful family-style Italian restaurant located at 200 W 44th St, New York. Known for its generous portions of traditional Southern Italian fare, it offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere ideal for sharing meals with loved ones. Open daily for lunch and dinner, Carmine's also serves up delicious desserts and offers a selection of wines and cocktails. Reservations are recommended.
• Cotta Osteria — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Cotta Osteria transports diners to a rustic Italian escape where the amber glow of candlelight flickers against exposed brick and the comforting aroma of charred crust wafts from a roaring wood-fired oven. Hand-stretched pizzas with perfectly blistered edges share the table with bowls of velvety pasta, each bite celebrating the simple, sun-drenched flavors of the Mediterranean. It is a vibrant neighborhood haunt where the clink of wine glasses and the hum of shared stories create an atmosphere of effortless, old-world charm.
• Bella Luna Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Bathed in the soft, amber glow of candlelight, Bella Luna captures the romance of a moonlit Italian evening where the air is fragrant with slow-simmered ragu and fresh-baked focaccia. Silken ribbons of house-made pasta and pours of velvety Chianti anchor an experience defined by rustic elegance and soulful hospitality. It is a sanctuary for the senses, where every shared plate and clink of crystal feels like a timeless celebration of the Old World.
• Gennaro — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Gennaro captures the soul of a rustic Italian kitchen, where the soft glow of candlelight illuminates tables laden with silken, hand-cut pastas and the intoxicating aroma of garlic and basil fills the air. Each plate brings together time-honored traditions and sun-ripened flavors, served in an atmosphere that hums with the warmth of a lively family gathering. It is an inviting escape where the
• Osteria Cotta — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Osteria Cotta effortlessly marries casual and romantic vibes. This inviting Italian eatery offers a delightful array of pizzas, pastas, and small plates. Perfect for brunch or dinner, the wine bar shines with happy hour specials and a charming sidewalk dining area. Customers appreciate its attentive service, making it an ideal spot for enjoying a memorable meal.
• Carmine's Italian Restaurant - Upper West Side — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the Upper West Side's Central Park West Historic District, Carmine's Italian Restaurant offers a delightful journey into traditional family-style Italian cuisine. Featuring generous portions of beloved dishes like calamari, pasta, and penne a la vodka, this upscale yet relaxed eatery is perfect for family gatherings and large parties. With attentive staff, an old-world ambiance, and options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery, Carmine's is a storied gem in NYC's dining scene.
• Freddie & Pepper's — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Freddie & Pepper's is a beloved family-owned pizzeria on the Upper West Side, serving New York-style pizzas since 1978. Known for its whole pies, slices, and delightful empanadas, the menu offers vegetarian and organic options. With a cozy counter-serve setup, it's an ideal spot for quick, casual dining with family. The authentic flavors and welcoming ambiance have earned it a stellar 4.4 rating from happy customers.
• Gennaro Restaurant — Italian · rated 4.4/5: Gennaro Restaurant is a casual Italian eatery nestled at 665 Amsterdam Ave, New York. Known for its traditional dishes, including vegetarian delights, this charming spot also offers wine, coffee, and indulgent desserts. With spacious outdoor seating and kid-friendly options, it’s perfect for family dinners. Rated 4.4 stars by 442 diners, it promises a delightful dining experience for all. Reservations recommended!
• Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant — Mediterranean · rated 4.4/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Bodrum Mediterranean Restaurant offers a charming ambiance and a diverse menu featuring Turkish and Mediterranean delights. Guests can savor dishes like manti, kebabs, and lamb tagine, alongside pizza and fresh hummus. Known for its quick service and cozy atmosphere, it’s a popular spot for families and groups. Reservations are recommended for dinner. Enjoy a meal with coffee, cocktails, beer, or wine at 584 Amsterdam Ave, New York.