Best Upscale Sandwich in Herald Square | Top 3 Upscale Spots

22 restaurants in Best Upscale Sandwich in Herald Square | Top 3 Upscale Spots

• Pavé — French · rated 5/5: The air at Pavé is thick with the comforting scent of toasted grain and warm yeast, drawing guests into a space where the humble baguette is elevated to a crisp, golden art form. Hand-stretched loaves with crackling crusts serve as the foundation for elegant pairings, from simple slathers of rich butter and aged Comté to sophisticated sandwiches layered with silken smoked salmon or the delicate crunch of fresh apple and creamy brie.
• Vanilla Gorilla Cafe — American · rated 5/5: This vibrant neighborhood hub hums with energy, drawing guests in with the irresistible scent of golden-toasted bread and bubbling mozzarella. The kitchen elevates the humble sandwich into a gourmet experience, layering premium ingredients into everything from the hearty Ultimate Breakfast to the crisp, savory Chicken Parm. Each bite, whether a signature flaky Pastrino or a zestful Poseidon Tuna, offers a masterclass in comfort, making it a sanctuary for those seeking bold, handheld flavors in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.
• Vezzo — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Bathed in the warm glow of exposed brick and flickering candlelight, this neighborhood gem invites diners into a rustic sanctuary where the air is perfumed with the scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour. Artisanal, paper-thin crusts shatter with a satisfying crunch, providing a delicate canvas for vibrant Mediterranean toppings and rich, velvety sauces that celebrate the soulful simplicity of Italian tradition. Every visit feels like a spirited escape to a bustling Roman side street, where time slows down over a shared bottle of robust red and a perfectly charred pie.
• Kaijitsu — Japanese · rated 4.5/5: A tranquil sanctuary where the minimalist elegance of Zen Buddhism meets the refined artistry of Shojin Ryori, inviting guests into a space of mindful contemplation. Each course is a poetic tribute to the seasons, elevating humble vegetables and wild-foraged ingredients into vibrant, multi-sensory compositions through centuries-old techniques. The experience unfolds with a quiet grace, offering a meditative journey through delicate textures and pure, earthy flavors that nourish both the body and the spirit.
• 2nd Ave Deli — American · rated 4.4/5: This legendary Manhattan institution welcomes guests with the intoxicating scent of garlic-rubbed pastrami and the comforting steam rising from bowls of golden matzo ball soup. Between the bustling energy of white-aproned servers and the nostalgic glow of neon, diners feast on towering sandwiches and crispy latkes that celebrate the rich, savory heritage of the classic New York deli.
• Ai Ki Ya — Japanese · rated 4.4/5: Ai Ki Ya captures the essence of Japanese hospitality in a space where the rhythmic pulse of the open kitchen meets an atmosphere of refined, understated elegance. Diners are treated to a sensory journey of vibrant, jewel-toned seafood and the smoky allure of the grill, all served with a precision that honors the natural beauty of every ingredient. It is a place where time seems to pause, allowing the delicate harmony of salt, umami, and vinegar to take center stage in a truly immersive dining experience.
• Bubba Gump Shrimp Company — Seafood · rated 4.3/5: This vibrant tribute to Southern coastal living transports diners to a whimsical world of cinematic nostalgia, where rustic wood accents and nautical treasures set the stage for a spirited family feast. The air is thick with the savory aroma of Cajun spices and sizzling seafood, inviting guests to roll up their sleeves for a bounty of buttery, peel-and-eat treasures and golden-fried delights that celebrate the simple joy of the Bayou.
• The Australian NYC — American · rated 4.3/5: This high-energy Midtown destination pulses with the spirited camaraderie of a premier sports lounge, where polished wood accents and glowing screens set the stage for an electric game-day atmosphere. The kitchen delivers a soulful take on American comfort, crafting charred, juice-dripping burgers and savory shared plates that pair perfectly with the clink of cold pint glasses and the roar of a cheering crowd.
• Mr. Broadway — Middle Eastern · rated 4.3/5: Located at 209 W 38th St in New York, Mr. Broadway is a contemporary kosher deli offering a diverse menu that includes sushi, American, and Mediterranean dishes. With a family-friendly atmosphere, the restaurant serves lunch, dinner, and a variety of desserts, including the highly recommended carrot cake. Open throughout the week (except Saturdays), it’s a great spot to enjoy delicious food and excellent service.
• Bhatti — Indian · rated 4.1/5: Bhatti captures the smoky, soulful essence of North Indian hearth cooking, where the air is thick with the aroma of toasted cumin and the rhythmic sizzle of the glowing tandoor. Guests are treated to a parade of charred, spice-rubbed delicacies and rich, slow-simmered curries that celebrate the deep, earthy flavors of traditional clay-oven techniques. This vibrant space brings together rustic charm and modern warmth, creating an immersive sensory journey through the heart of Indian spice.
• Grey Bar & Restaurant — American · rated 4/5: Grey Bar & Restaurant offers a sleek, contemporary escape where the vibrant colors of artisan salads meet the savory depth of perfectly seared proteins. Guests can linger over a delicate plate of ahi tuna or sink into a signature charred burger, all within an atmosphere that seamlessly blends urban sophistication with the comforting warmth of a neighborhood favorite.
• Flying Cock — American · rated 4/5: This high-energy social hub pulses with a playful spirit, inviting guests to dive into a bold menu of globally-inspired small plates designed for sharing and celebration. The kitchen masterfully bridges continents, serving up everything from crackling Korean-style wings and zesty tuna tartare tacos to inventive Reuben spring rolls that offer a surprising, savory crunch. Between the sizzle of loaded bar nachos and the delicate steam of pork belly dumplings, every bite feels like a discovery in a space where the atmosphere is as electric as the flavors.
• Pebble Bar — Seafood · rated 4/5: Perched within a legendary townhouse, this sophisticated hideaway hums with the energy of a classic New York lounge, where moody lighting and polished wood set the stage for an evening of refined indulgence. The kitchen elevates the art of the bar snack, serving up glistening towers of chilled oysters and buttery lobster rolls alongside savory deviled eggs and crisp, salty bites. It is a place where the timeless allure of a well-poured cocktail meets a menu of coastal-inspired delicacies, creating an atmosphere that feels both effortlessly chic and intimately welcoming.
• Lena's Italian Kitchen — Italian · rated 4/5: Lena’s Italian Kitchen captures the heart of a bustling family home, where the irresistible aroma of toasted garlic bread and hand-rolled meatballs invites guests to linger over tables laden with classic comforts. From the spicy kick of calamari arrabbiata to the steam rising from delicate bowls of tortellini en brodo, every dish celebrates the soulful simplicity of Italian tradition in a space that feels both nostalgic and vibrantly alive.
• Nino's 46 — Italian · rated 4/5: Nino’s 46 pulses with a sophisticated energy, offering a chic retreat where the table is quickly filled with vibrant, shareable treasures like creamy whipped ricotta and golden, molten fried burrata. The kitchen masterfully balances rustic indulgence and refined artistry, pairing the earthy aroma of truffled mac and cheese bites with the bright, delicate sweetness of strawberry-topped burrata and flame-kissed octopus. This lively destination celebrates the joy of the shared meal, blending modern culinary creativity with a warm, soulful spirit.
• Other Half Brewing — American · rated 4/5: This vibrant urban taproom pulses with energy, drawing craft beer enthusiasts into a sleek, industrial space where the scent of warm, salt-dusted pretzels mingles with the citrusy perfume of freshly poured IPAs. From the hazy, tropical notes of their signature imperial brews to the crisp snap of a golden lager, every glass is a celebration of modern brewing artistry, perfectly complemented by a rotating selection of hearty sandwiches and savory snacks.
• Best Bagel & Coffee — American: The air is thick with the irresistible aroma of freshly roasted coffee and sizzling griddles, drawing a lively morning crowd into this bustling neighborhood staple. Hand-rolled bagels with a perfect golden chew serve as the foundation for towering stacks of salty Taylor ham, fluffy eggs, and molten cheese that define the quintessential New York breakfast experience. Whether fueling up with a protein-packed power sandwich or lingering over a hearty omelette platter, every bite captures the comforting, high-energy spirit of a classic city start.
• Skylight Diner — American: Sunlight pours through expansive windows to illuminate this polished take on the classic American eatery, where the nostalgic hum of a bustling kitchen creates an atmosphere of effortless warmth. Guests find comfort in plates of golden breakfast staples and hearty, hand-crafted sandwiches, while vibrant salads offer a crisp, garden-fresh counterpoint to the soulful, time-honored flavors served throughout the day.
• BLACKBARN Restaurant — American: Stepping into this urban sanctuary feels like entering a refined farmhouse, where reclaimed wood and warm lighting create an atmosphere of rustic sophistication. The kitchen celebrates the seasons with an eclectic menu that bridges the gap between comfort and artistry, from the earthy richness of wild mushroom toast to the bright, delicate layers of big-eye tuna tartare. Whether lingering over a bubbling bowl of French onion soup or sharing a vibrant plate of burratina and prosciutto, guests are treated to a soulful culinary journey that feels both grounded and worldly.
• Felix Roasting Co. — American: Step into a world of opulent maximalism where velvet textures and ornate copper accents transform the daily coffee ritual into a lavish sensory performance. The air carries the delicate fragrance of rare single-origin beans, from the bright, floral notes of pink bourbon to the vibrant elegance of ceremonial matcha, all served with meticulous artistry. This sophisticated sanctuary invites guests to linger over expertly pulled espressos and artisanal filter blends, offering a refined escape that celebrates the beauty in every pour.
• Dan & John's Wings — American: The air at Dan & John’s Wings hums with high-energy vibes and the mouthwatering scent of tangy glazes, inviting guests to dive into a communal feast of perfectly crisped comfort. Heaping platters of golden traditional wings and mountains of salty tater tots take center stage, creating a lively atmosphere where messy hands and shared boxes of savory chicken sandwiches define the ultimate casual dining indulgence.
• Friedman's — American: This vibrant destination reimagines the classic American eatery as a warm, bustling haven where nostalgic comfort meets a playful, modern spirit. The air carries the soul-soothing aroma of golden chicken matzo ball soup, perfectly complemented by indulgent, bubbling mac and cheese and the bright, zesty crunch of spicy tuna crispy rice. It is a place where every shared plate—from molten spinach artichoke dip to delicate potstickers—invites guests to linger in an atmosphere that feels both familiar and refreshingly sophisticated.