Best Italian Restaurants in Lincoln Square | Top Rated Italian Food

30 restaurants in Best Italian Restaurants in Lincoln Square | Top Rated Italian Food

• Norma — Italian · rated 5/5: Norma transports diners to the sun-drenched heart of Sicily, where the air is perfumed with the scent of charred aubergine and slow-simmered tomatoes. Hand-crafted pastas and vibrant, salt-kissed seafood take center stage in a space that glows with Mediterranean warmth, inviting guests to lose themselves in the rhythmic hum of a bustling trattoria. It is a soulful celebration of Italian heritage, where every plate tells a story of tradition reimagined with modern, artful flair.
• Ballfields Café — American · rated 5/5: Bathed in natural light, this charming parkside escape invites guests to linger over the comforting aroma of toasted paninis and golden-crusted pizzas fresh from the oven. The counter gleams with an artisanal spread of buttery pastries and decadent sliced cakes, perfectly paired with a robust espresso for a midday lift or a chilled glass of wine as the afternoon fades into evening.
• Rosetta — Italian · rated 5/5: The scent of golden, oven-fresh dough fills this vibrant artisanal space, where the craft of the Italian bakery is elevated through a stunning array of hand-stretched focaccias and crisp, airy pizza in teglia. From the paper-thin, cheese-filled layers of traditional Recco-style crusts to wholesome sandwiches tucked into vibrant turmeric and multi-grain breads, every bite celebrates a harmony of rustic textures and contemporary flair. It is a sun-drenched haven for bread lovers, offering a sophisticated yet soulful journey through the diverse landscapes of Mediterranean flour and fire.
• Alanza — Italian · rated 5/5: Nestled in the heart of New York at 2030 Broadway, Alanza is an inviting Italian restaurant perfect for family dinners with kids' menus available. Open daily from 4:00 PM to 9:30 PM, Alanza caters to all diners with payment options including credit and debit cards. Enjoy a delightful range of vegetarian dishes and decadent desserts, with options for dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Visit [website](https://order.wonder.com/Upper%20West%20Side/Alanza%20HDR%20UWS) for more.
• Noi Due Carne — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Bathed in a warm, sophisticated glow, this modern Italian steakhouse invites guests into a world where the smoky aroma of the grill meets the refined artistry of the Mediterranean. Masterfully seared prime cuts and rich, house-made pastas take center stage, delivering a symphony of bold flavors in a space that feels both intimate and high-energy. It is a destination where the tradition of the butcher’s craft is elevated by sleek design and a passion for soulful, fire-kissed cuisine.
• Via Toscana — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Via Toscana is a cozy Italian restaurant nestled near Times Square, offering a delightful array of dinner, dessert, and drinks. With a menu featuring favorites like calamari, pasta, and tiramisu, and a well-curated wine list, it's an ideal spot for both family dinners and intimate gatherings. Guests rave about the attentive service and the owner’s menu recommendations. Expect to spend around $30-50 for a memorable meal.
• Carla — Italian · rated 4.8/5: Nestled in the vibrant heart of Hell's Kitchen, Carla offers a relaxed dining experience with a global twist. This trendy American restaurant and bar is known for its eclectic, vegan-friendly menu featuring dishes like shrimp tacos and chicken enchiladas. The cozy, plant-decorated space is ideal for families and solo diners alike. With impeccable service and a lively happy hour, Carla ensures a delightful visit for everyone.
• My Pie Pizzeria Romana — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Step into a slice of Rome where the rhythmic sound of shears cutting through crisp, airy crust mingles with the enticing aroma of herb-infused oils and San Marzano tomatoes. Long, rectangular trays showcase a vibrant tapestry of artisanal toppings resting atop a signature dough that shatters with a satisfying crunch, inviting diners to explore a rotating gallery of bold, seasonal flavors. This bustling space captures the effortless charm of an Italian piazza, offering a sensory escape that celebrates the authentic spirit of Roman street food.
• LaVista Pizza — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Perched where the golden glow of a wood-fired oven meets a panoramic backdrop, LaVista Pizza invites diners into a vibrant space filled with the irresistible scent of blistered dough and simmering San Marzano tomatoes. Artisanal pies emerge from the flames with perfectly charred crusts and molten pools of buffalo mozzarella, capturing the sun-drenched essence of Italy in every crisp, savory bite. It is a place where the clink of wine glasses and the lively energy of the open kitchen transform a simple meal into a spirited celebration of Mediterranean flavor.
• Sempre Oggi — Italian · rated 4.7/5: Sempre Oggi captures the fleeting beauty of the seasons within a luminous, modern space that pulses with the warmth of spirited Italian hospitality. Here, the kitchen transforms peak-harvest ingredients into vibrant, hand-crafted pastas and coastal-inspired plates that celebrate the simple joy of the present moment. It is a soulful retreat where timeless Old World traditions are reimagined with a fresh, contemporary energy, inviting guests to linger over every sun-kissed bite.
• Sacco Pizza — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Step into a timeless corner of the neighborhood where the rhythmic slap of dough and the warmth of a glowing oven create a sanctuary for lovers of the perfect slice. Each thin-crust masterpiece emerges with a delicate char and a molten layer of tangy sauce and creamy cheese, offering a masterclass in simple, soulful Italian flavors. It is a place where the bustle of the street fades away, replaced by the comforting, flour-dusted charm of a true local institution.
• Emmy Squared — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Emmy Squared reimagines the classic pizzeria experience with its signature Detroit-style squares, where a lacy, caramelized cheese crust gives way to a pillowy center topped with vibrant streaks of sauce. The atmosphere buzzes with a playful, neighborhood energy, inviting diners to linger over indulgent double-stack burgers and shareable Italian-inspired plates that celebrate bold, comforting flavors.
• Nocello — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nocello invites guests into a refined yet intimate escape where the soft hum of conversation mingles with the intoxicating scent of fresh basil and toasted garlic. The kitchen transforms simple, high-quality ingredients into masterfully plated Italian classics, from velvet-smooth risottos to perfectly seared proteins that sing with Mediterranean herbs. It is a destination where the art of slow dining is rediscovered, leaving diners enveloped in a sense of warmth and culinary nostalgia.
• IL BARETTO TO GO — Italian · rated 4.6/5: IL BARETTO TO GO is an inviting Italian restaurant located in Hell's Kitchen, New York, specializing in authentic Roman pizza, pasta, panini, and homemade gelato. With a casual, cozy atmosphere that includes outdoor seating, it's a great spot for families and groups alike. Open for brunch, lunch, and dinner, the menu also features fresh salads, desserts, and a variety of coffee and canned drinks. Prices range from $10-$20, making it an affordable and delightful dining experience. Contact: (212) 245-0490
• Carla — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Welcome to Carla, a cozy restaurant and cocktail bar in Long Island City. With a menu inspired by global comfort food, Carla serves up popular dishes like tacos, burgers, and chicken fajitas, alongside vegetarian and vegan options. Guests rave about the delightful brunch and creative cocktails such as hibiscus margaritas and mezcal palomas. The tropical, two-story venue boasts a warm atmosphere, complete with live music and exceptional service. Bring the family, including kids and pets, and enjoy both indoor and outdoor seating. Join us for happy hour and delicious meals that will make you feel right at home. Reservable | Family-Friendly | Live Music | Happy Hour | Creative Cocktails | Vegan Options
• Norma Hell's Kitchen — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in Hell's Kitchen, Norma is a delightful Sicilian-inspired gem offering a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Known for its comforting pizzas, pastas, and vegetarian options, this Italian haven is perfect for date nights and family dinners. With excellent service, soft lighting, and inviting outdoor seating, it's an ideal spot to savor dishes like arancini, pasta alla norma, and calamari. Enjoy a meal at Norma and discover why it's a beloved favorite in the city.
• Masseria dei Vini — ini is a well- · rated 4.6/5: Masseria dei Vini is a charming upscale Italian restaurant and wine bar nestled in Hell's Kitchen. Popular for both lunch and dinner, the restaurant offers classic Italian dishes like pizza, ravioli, and spaghetti al nero con vongole, alongside vegetarian and healthy options. With a cozy atmosphere, attentive staff, and a robust selection of wines, it’s a perfect spot for a delightful dining experience. Reservations are recommended.
• Il Melograno — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Il Melograno, nestled at 501 W 51st St, New York, is a charming Italian eatery that captivates diners with its authentic Sicilian fare and intimate, romantic atmosphere. With a stellar rating of 4.6 and over 600 reviews, this local gem is perfect for date nights and special occasions. The restaurant offers an array of traditional dishes, delightful desserts, and a fine selection of wine, making it a must-visit spot for Italian cuisine enthusiasts.
• B Side Pizza Bar — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the vibrant heart of Hell's Kitchen, B Side Pizza Bar offers a cozy ambiance and a creative menu featuring specialty brick-oven pizzas alongside seasonal small plates. Indulge in favorites like the killer bee pizza, and complement your meal with craft beers, wines, or cocktails. With a warm atmosphere, friendly service, and inviting music, it's the perfect spot for a memorable evening out.
• SESAMO - Italian Restaurant Hell's Kitchen NYC — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Located in Hell's Kitchen, SESAMO blends Italian and Asian-inspired flavors in a cozy, romantic atmosphere. Renowned for dishes like coconut miso salmon and matcha tiramisu, the restaurant offers brunch, lunch, and dinner, with table and counter service. The friendly staff and extensive wine selection enhance the dining experience, making SESAMO a unique destination for fusion cuisine lovers. Reserve your spot today!
• Parla — Italian · rated 4.6/5: Nestled in the Central Park West Historic District, Parla offers a delightful dining experience with its New York-style pizza and Italian-inspired cocktails. The menu features unique pizzas like the hot honey margarita and clam pie, alongside classics such as meatballs and burrata. Popular for both lunch and dinner, Parla is a hit with families and offers fast, friendly service. With a rating of 4.6 stars from 136 reviews, it's a recommended spot for great pizza and drinks.
• The Meatball Shop — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This vibrant, industrial-chic haunt pulses with energy as the savory aroma of slow-simmered sauces and hand-rolled comfort wafts from the bustling kitchen. Guests craft their own perfect plates from a palette of tender meatballs and artisanal sauces, pairing hearty helpings of creamy polenta or crusty bread with spirited cocktails. The experience reimagines the traditional Italian Sunday dinner with a playful, modern edge, where every bite feels like a warm and soulful embrace.
• Salumeria Rosi — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This intimate Tuscan-inspired gem transports diners to a bustling Roman deli, where shelves overflow with artisanal oils and the air carries the irresistible aroma of freshly sliced salumi. Guests linger over marble tables, sharing vibrant small plates and expertly curated meat boards that celebrate the bold, rustic flavors of Italy’s countryside. Every glass of wine and bite of aged cheese feels like a curated invitation to slow down and savor the soulful art of the Italian table.
• Farinella — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Sun-drenched windows and the intoxicating scent of rising dough invite diners into this vibrant Italian sanctuary, where the rhythmic dusting of flour sets the stage for a meal rooted in artisanal tradition. Hand-stretched pizzas emerge from the heat with perfectly blistered crusts, while ribbons of golden pasta are tossed in sun-ripened sauces that celebrate the soulful, rustic elegance of the Mediterranean.
• Tuscany Steakhouse — Steakhouse · rated 4.5/5: Tuscany Steakhouse captures the intersection of old-world Italian charm and the grandeur of a premier Manhattan chophouse, where the amber glow of the dining room and the crisp snap of white linens promise an evening of refined indulgence. The air is thick with the savory perfume of USDA Prime steaks dry-aged to perfection and seared at high heat, complemented by the delicate textures of hand-rolled pastas and a cellar of robust, full-bodied reds. It is a sanctuary of timeless hospitality, where every sizzling plate and attentive gesture creates an atmosphere of celebration and culinary mastery.
• Polpette 71 — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Tucked away like a well-kept secret, this cozy Italian nook wraps diners in a warm embrace of candlelit tables and the intoxicating scent of garlic-infused olive oil. The kitchen honors tradition through tender, melt-in-your-mouth meatballs and silky handmade pastas that capture the rustic elegance of a Sunday family feast. It is a soulful retreat where vibrant flavors meet the quiet charm of the neighborhood, creating an experience that feels both indulgent and deeply familiar.
• Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side — Italian · rated 4.5/5: This vibrant Upper West Side corner pulses with an eclectic, indie spirit, where colorful folk art lines the walls and the air carries the irresistible aroma of cornmeal-dusted crusts baking to a perfect crisp. The kitchen harmonizes the spicy soul of the Bayou with traditional Italian roots, crafting whimsical, thin-crust masterpieces topped with bold, zesty ingredients that ignite the senses. Under the warm glow of neon signs, diners find a high-spirited neighborhood sanctuary that transforms a simple slice into a flavorful, artistic celebration of New York’s diverse culinary landscape.
• Giardino 54 — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, Giardino 54 is a charming Italian restaurant and bar inspired by an indoor garden theme. Perfect for both family outings and large parties, the cozy setting features a delightful patio. With a well-curated wine list, craft cocktails, and popular brunch options, it's easy to see why dishes like pasta, lasagna, and ravioli are crowd favorites. Enjoy happy hour specials amidst knowledgeable and attentive staff. Customers typically spend $30-50 per visit.
• Felice 71- Columbus — Italian · rated 4.5/5: Located in the Central Park West Historic District, Felice 71- Columbus offers a fine-dining Italian experience. With a cozy atmosphere, extensive wine bar, and a menu featuring classic dishes like pasta, fish, and meat, this romantic spot is perfect for any occasion. The attentive staff and inviting basement lounge add to the allure. Whether for dine-in, takeout, or curbside pickup, Felice promises a delightful culinary experience.
• Rampoldi New York — Mediterranean · rated 4.5/5: Nestled off Broadway near Lincoln Center, Rampoldi New York boasts an elegant blend of Italian and French cuisine, perfect for a pre-show meal or special occasion. With a 4.5-star rating, locals adore its expertly crafted dishes and sophisticated ambiance. Enjoy a glass of wine, delectable desserts, and attentive service. Convenient curbside pickup and various payment options make dining here a breeze. Find them at 49 W 64th St, New York.