Best Mexican Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Top Rated Mexican Food

30 restaurants in Best Mexican Restaurants in Carnegie Hill | Top Rated Mexican Food

• Burritos y Mas — Mexican · rated 5/5: The air at this vibrant neighborhood haunt is thick with the savory aroma of seared meats and the irresistible crunch of warm, salt-dusted chips meeting zesty house-made salsa. Hand-stretched tortillas arrive generously overstuffed with charred, seasoned steak or tender, slow-simmered pork, creating a hearty and soulful experience that celebrates bold, sun-drenched flavors in every satisfying bite.
• El Tepeyac Grocery — Mexican · rated 5/5: This vibrant neighborhood hub pulses with the savory aroma of slow-cooked meats and the bright, citrusy tang of house-made salsas. Tucked behind shelves of colorful Mexican spices and imported staples, the bustling kitchen crafts hand-pressed tortillas and tender, spice-rubbed carnitas that offer a soulful taste of home-style cooking. It is a hidden gem where the hum of the community meets the sizzle of the plancha, inviting guests to linger over authentic flavors in an unpretentious, welcoming space.
• Conmigo — Mexican · rated 5/5: Soft candlelight flickers against warm terracotta walls, creating an intimate sanctuary where the rhythmic clink of cocktail shakers mingles with the low hum of shared stories. Vibrant plates arrive in a colorful procession, showcasing a bold tapestry of Latin-inspired flavors that range from zesty, lime-brightened crudos to slow-simmered meats that fall apart at the touch of a fork. This spirited neighborhood gem captures the essence of communal dining, turning every meal into a soulful celebration of connection and craft.
• Jalapeño Deli — Mexican · rated 4.8/5: Located at 1629 Lexington Ave, New York, Jalapeño Deli is a delightful Mexican restaurant earning rave reviews with a 4.8-star rating from 41 patrons. Known for its authentic, homemade dishes like burritos and tortas, this family-friendly spot ensures a charming culinary experience. Open daily from 8 AM to 9 PM, Jalapeño Deli offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, truly a must-visit for any foodie.
• Soledad — Mexican · rated 4.7/5: Sun-drenched colors and the rhythmic patter of handmade tortillas define the soul of Soledad, a sanctuary where the vibrant spirit of Mexico comes alive through layers of smoke and spice. From the first sip of a salt-rimmed mezcal cocktail to the rich, velvet depth of a traditional mole, every dish tells a story of heritage served in an atmosphere of effortless, candlelit warmth.
• El Tepeyac Taqueria 97 St — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: El Tepeyac Taqueria 97 St is a casual spot on Lexington Ave in New York, serving a delightful variety of Mexican staples and breakfast options. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly service, this restaurant is both family-friendly and accommodating, offering reservations, dine-in, takeout, and delivery services. With a solid rating of 4.6, it’s a popular choice among locals and visitors. Enjoy delicious meals paired with coffee, wine, or beer, and stop by between 8:00 AM and midnight, with extended hours on weekends.
• Earl's Beer and Cheese — American · rated 4.6/5: Nestled on Park Avenue, Earl's Beer and Cheese offers a laid-back atmosphere where craft brews pair seamlessly with a cheese-focused menu. Savory bar bites like grilled cheese sandwiches and tacos make it a favorite among locals. The spot's cozy vibes and friendly staff ensure a delightful dining experience. Open for brunch on weekends and known for its inviting ambiance, Earl's is a must-visit for cheese lovers and beer enthusiasts alike.
• MELI'S DELICIOUS CORP — Mexican · rated 4.6/5: Nestled at 159 E 103rd St, Manhattan, NY, MELI'S DELICIOUS CORP is a charming eatery that offers a delightful culinary experience. Open Monday through Saturday from 8:00 AM to 7:00 PM, this spot is perfect for a refreshing juice, a nutritious salad, or a savory dish like the basa steamed fish with vegetables. With dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, it caters to every need. Enjoy a visit to this delightful restaurant for healthy and delicious food!
• Burritos y Mas — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Burritos y Mas pulses with the vibrant energy of a bustling street market, where the air is thick with the smoky scent of charred chiles and seasoned meats sizzling on the griddle. Oversized flour tortillas are expertly rolled around layers of creamy beans, zesty rice, and bright, house-made salsas, creating a hearty, flavor-packed experience that captures the soulful warmth of traditional Mexican comfort food.
• El Tepeyac Taqueria — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: El Tepeyac Taqueria pulses with the vibrant energy of a neighborhood landmark, where the air is heavy with the intoxicating aroma of charred carne asada and simmering spices. Guests gather around sun-drenched tables to savor hand-pressed tortillas overflowing with succulent, slow-cooked meats and bright, house-made salsas that dance on the palate. It is a sensory celebration of authentic Mexican flavors, where every bite captures the warmth and soul of traditional street-side dining.
• El Aguila — Mexican · rated 4.5/5: Nestled in the heart of East Harlem, El Aguila is a cozy Mexican restaurant known for its comforting and quick bites. Pop in for breakfast, lunch, or dinner and savor staples like tacos, burritos, and tortas, with popular picks including al pastor and barbacoa. Ideal for solo diners and families, this casual spot offers affordable dining (typically $10-$20) and convenient ordering options.
• Toloache — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: A vibrant Mexican bistro where the smoky perfume of a wood-burning oven and the rhythmic shake of artisanal cocktails create an atmosphere of sophisticated celebration. The open kitchen serves as a theatrical stage where rustic soul meets urban elegance, bringing together hand-pressed tortillas, complex moles, and the bright, bold flavors of contemporary Mexico in every spirited bite.
• Lolita's Kitchen & Burger House — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: Located at 1364 Lexington Ave #1, Lolita's Kitchen & Burger House is a cozy spot offering a delightful array of Mexican cuisine and American classics. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, the restaurant is a great choice for families and groups. Enjoy tacos, burritos, and burgers, paired with your favorite margarita. With a solid 4.4 rating from 331 reviews, Lolita's promises a pleasant dining experience.
• Burritos Y Mas NY — Mexican · rated 4.4/5: Discover Burritos Y Mas NY, a cozy Mexican eatery located in East Harlem at 1571 Lexington Ave. Specializing in quick, delightful bites for lunch and dinner, the menu features favorites like tacos, burritos, quesadillas, and taco salads, with vegetarian and vegan options. Enjoy the casual counter-serve setting, dine-in, or opt for takeout or delivery. Perfect for families, this spot ensures a satisfying experience for all.
• Maz Mescal — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Stepping into this vibrant neighborhood sanctuary feels like a festive escape, where hand-painted tiles and warm lighting set the stage for a soulful exploration of Mexican heritage. The air hums with the rhythmic shake of agave cocktails and the savory perfume of slow-cooked moles, inviting diners to linger over plates that burst with the bright acidity of lime and the deep, smoky heat of roasted chiles.
• Kappo Masa — Japanese · rated 4.3/5: Nestled in Lenox Hill, Kappo Masa by acclaimed chef Masa Takayama offers a serene subterranean escape where sushi and other Japanese delights are expertly crafted for lunch and dinner. Savor the freshness of the sushi and the unique flavors of dishes like duck tacos and uni custard in a cozy, romantic ambiance. With top-notch service and a variety of beverages, this fine-dining spot promises a memorable culinary experience. Reservations are a must.
• Maz Mezcal — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Maz Mezcal, a family-run gem on the Upper East Side since 1987, offers a delightful array of Mexican dishes including fajitas, mole, and nachos. Known for its casual ambiance and kid-friendly setting, this spot also features a bar and caters to events. Enjoy fast service and must-try margaritas, all at 316 East 86th St, New York. For reservations, call +1 212-472-1599.
• Cantinflas Mexican Deli — Mexican · rated 4.3/5: Located at 1916 3rd Ave, New York, Cantinflas Mexican Deli is a beloved spot for authentic Mexican cuisine. Rated 4.3 stars by 20 reviewers, it’s cherished for its friendly atmosphere and tasty offerings, including must-try tacos and tortas. Open daily with convenient hours, Cantinflas accepts various payment methods. Whether you're grabbing coffee or a full meal, this family-owned deli delivers quality and warmth to the East Harlem neighborhood.
• Móle — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Móle invites guests into a warm, dimly lit sanctuary where the air is heavy with the intoxicating scent of roasted cacao and charred peppers. Hand-pressed tortillas provide a rustic canvas for velvety, multi-layered sauces that dance between sweet and savory, creating a dining experience that feels both deeply ancestral and vibrantly modern.
• Conmigo — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Conmigo invites diners into a sun-drenched space where the vibrant colors of Mexico meet the soulful warmth of a shared meal. The air is thick with the scent of charred peppers and slow-simmered moles, setting the stage for a feast of hand-pressed tortillas and zesty, lime-brightened flavors that dance on the palate. It’s a lively sanctuary where every clink of a salt-rimmed glass feels like a celebration of community and craft.
• Tacos & Tequila — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Discover a cozy haven of Mexican cuisine at Tacos & Tequila, nestled at 1742 2nd Ave, New York. Renowned for its delectable tacos and traditional dishes, this vibrant spot offers refreshing margaritas and cocktails to complement your meal. Boasting a solid 4.2 rating from 187 reviews, it features outdoor seating and is perfect for brunch, lunch, or dinner. Visit for a delightful dining experience!
• The Red Grill — Steakhouse · rated 4.2/5: Located at 1701 2nd Ave, New York, The Red Grill is a relaxed eatery specializing in traditional Mexican cuisine, including enchiladas, fajitas, and tacos. With a 4.2-star rating based on 185 reviews, it's a family-friendly spot, offering free street parking, outdoor seating, and a variety of drink options from coffee to cocktails. Open daily from 10 AM to 10 PM, it’s perfect for lunch, dinner, and desserts.
• Sabor A Mexico — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Located at 1744 1st Ave., New York, Sabor A Mexico is a casual, vibrant spot serving up classic Mexican favorites like tacos, burritos, and margaritas. With a family-friendly atmosphere and attentive staff, it’s perfect for groups and kids. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM, this eatery offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Enjoy their selection of wines, beers, and cocktails while you savor their delicious dishes.
• Móle Mexican Bar & Grill - Upper East Side — Mexican · rated 4.2/5: Located at 1735 2nd Ave in New York, Móle Mexican Bar & Grill brings the vibrant flavors of traditional Mexican cuisine to Manhattan’s Upper East Side. With a 4.2-star rating and over 500 reviews, this casual eatery offers a delightful range of dishes, from savory mains to delectable desserts, all accompanied by a fine selection of wines and margaritas. Perfect for family outings, you'll find a welcoming atmosphere and a dedicated children’s menu. Both curbside pickup and outdoor seating are available for a flexible dining experience. Open daily from 12 PM to 10 PM, it’s an inviting spot for lunch, brunch, dinner, and happy hour.
• El Paso Taqueria — Mexican · rated 4.1/5: Nestled in East Harlem, El Paso Taqueria is a cozy and casual Mexican restaurant known for its comfort food and quick bites. With a vibrant decor and options for indoor and outdoor seating, it's perfect for groups, families, and sports fans alike. Their menu, featuring guacamole, nachos, burritos, and chicken enchiladas, pairs perfectly with a variety of drinks including margaritas and happy hour specials. Open daily for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, El Paso Taqueria offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery, ensuring a delightful experience for all visitors.
• La Fonda — Mexican · rated 4/5: La Fonda transports diners to a vibrant Mexican plaza, where the rhythmic pat-pat of handmade tortillas and the smoky aroma of slow-roasted meats create an atmosphere of festive warmth. Each dish celebrates bold, ancestral flavors, from the complex depth of a velvety mole to the zesty brightness of lime-cured seafood, all served in a space alive with color and the clink of artisanal glassware.
• Sabor A Mexico — Mexican · rated 4/5: Brightly hued murals and the intoxicating aroma of charred peppers welcome guests into this spirited haven, where the essence of Mexican tradition is celebrated through every vibrant dish. From the sizzle of marinated meats to the delicate crunch of house-made chips, the experience captures a festive energy that pairs perfectly with artisanal tequilas and the warm glow of a bustling dining room.
• La Fonda — Mexican · rated 4/5: La Fonda invites guests into a sun-drenched space where the rhythmic patter of hand-pressed tortillas and the smoky aroma of slow-simmered chilies create an atmosphere of rustic warmth. Vibrant plates bursting with bold, traditional flavors are served alongside salt-rimmed cocktails, offering a soulful dining experience that feels like a spirited celebration of heritage and home.
• Tacos Mi Mexico — Mexican · rated 4/5: Tacos Mi Mexico captures the vibrant spirit of a traditional Mexican taqueria, where the rhythmic sound of cleavers on cutting boards and the intoxicating scent of charred meats fill the air. Warm, hand-pressed tortillas cradle succulent al pastor and tender carnitas, topped with a bright confetti of fresh cilantro and zesty salsas that dance on the palate. It is a lively, unpretentious destination where every bite offers a festive celebration of bold, sun-drenched flavors and authentic heritage.
• Perla del Pacifico — Mexican · rated 3.9/5: Perla del Pacífico, located at 9551 Roosevelt Ave in Queens, NY, offers a delightful dining experience with a 3.9-star rating based on 64 reviews. Open daily from 9 AM to 8 PM, this family-friendly eatery serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, including desserts and a selection of beers. Conveniently, it accepts credit cards and provides takeout, delivery, and dine-in options. The restaurant is celebrated for its flavorful dishes and attentive service.