Made in New York Pizza – Italian
The air hums with the energy of a classic city slice shop, where the irresistible scent of bubbling mozzarella and toasted flour spills out onto the sidewalk from glowing ovens. Masterfully tossed dough emerges as golden, thin-crust rounds, ranging from the timeless, salty snap of pepperoni to the creamy, indulgent swirl of a vodka-sauced masterpiece. Every bite captures the soulful, no-nonsense spirit of an authentic neighborhood staple, offering a quintessential urban experience that feels both nostalgic and vibrant.
421, Amsterdam Avenue, New York, NY, 10024 +16463626657 https://madeinnewyorkpizza.com0Cuisine: Italian
Price range: $
Dietary options: dairy-free, gluten-free, halal, high-protein, keto, low-carb, vegan, vegetarian, heart-healthy, low-fat, low-sodium, pescatarian, plant-based, anti-inflammatory, atkins, dash-sodium-reduced, gerd, high-fiber, low-cholesterol, south-beach, aip, alkaline, carnivore, renal, tlc, volumetrics, zone, lectin-free, macrobiotic, slow-carb
Diet fit at Made in New York Pizza
Dairy-Free at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 2 dairy-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie and Vegan Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Gluten-Free at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 1 gluten-free-tagged dish on its current menu, including Gluten-Free Personal Pie. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Halal at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 20 halal-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie, Original Grandma Square and Upside Down Sicilian Square. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
High-Protein at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 1 high-protein-tagged dish on its current menu, including Chicken Roll. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Keto at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 2 keto-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Smart Water and Gold Peak Ice Tea. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Low-Carb at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 2 low-carb-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Smart Water and Gold Peak Ice Tea. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Vegan at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 5 vegan-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie, Vegan Pie and Mexican Soda. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
Vegetarian at Made in New York Pizza
Made in New York Pizza in New York has 20 vegetarian-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie, Vodka Round and Original Grandma Square. Tags come from dish-level menu analysis and update when the menu changes.
How tags work: Dish-level menu analysis by Chefi's rule-based diet engine with AI assistance; nutrition values are estimated from ingredients unless marked verified. Allergen and certification claims are never inferred.
What to order at Made in New York Pizza
| Dish | Net carbs | Protein |
|---|---|---|
| Yo Paulie Round | 42.6 g | 70.3 g |
| Chicken Roll | 36.5 g | 59 g |
| Upside Down Sicilian Square | 0 g | 47.6 g |
| Margherita Round | 18.7 g | 37.2 g |
| Eggplant Sicilian Square | 22.3 g | 34.9 g |
| Street Fair Round | 38.3 g | 32.4 g |
| Vegan Pie | 32.7 g | 29.2 g |
| Vegan Cheese Pie | 17.9 g | 28.1 g |
| Vodka-roni Round | 21.6 g | 25.3 g |
| Classic Sicilian Square | 0 g | 23.8 g |
| Spicy Pepperoni Square | 21.6 g | 23.8 g |
| Vodka Round | 2.3 g | 18.5 g |
Nutrition values are estimated from ingredients.
Currently closed
Hours
- Monday - Thursday
- 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
- Friday - Saturday
- 11:00 AM - 1:00 AM
- Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Menu
Round Pizzas
Authentic hand-tossed round pies and slices.
- Plain Cheese Round - $4: Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Pepperoni Round - $5: California Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano, Pepperoni Available at: dinner, lunch
- Mushroom Round - $5: Tomatoes, Mozzarella, Pecorino, Oregano, Fresh Mushrooms Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Margherita Round - $5: Plum Tomato Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino, Fresh Garlic, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- Vodka Round - $5.25: Vodka Sauce, Pecorino, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Pescatarian Available at: dinner, lunch
- White Round - $5.25: Four Cheese Blend, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- White Spinach Round - $5.5: Blend of Cheeses, Fresh Garlic, Spinach, Ricotta Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- BBQ Chicken Round - $5.75: Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken Marinated In Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ Sauce Available at: dinner, lunch
- Buffalo Chicken Round - $5.75: Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken Marinated In Frank’s Red Hot Sauce, Ranch Drizzle Available at: dinner, lunch
- Street Fair Round - $5.75: Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino, oregano, sweet Italian sausage, white onion, hot cherry peppers Dietary tags: High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Yo Paulie Round - $5.75: Tomatoes, mozzarella, pecorino romano, oregano, pepperoni, hot cherry peppers, honey drizzle Available at: dinner, lunch
- Vodka-roni Round - $6: Vodka sauce, pecorino, fresh mozzarella, basil, e.v.o.o, spicy pepperoni cups Available at: dinner, lunch
- Margherita Stracciatella Round - $6: Tomatoes, Pecorino, Post-oven Stracciatella, Basil, E.V.O.O Available at: dinner, lunch
Square Pizzas
Thick, crispy NYC-style square slices.
- Classic Sicilian Square - $5: Slow-Cooked Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Sicilian Oregano, Pecorino Romano Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Upside Down Sicilian Square - $5: Slow-Cooked Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, Sicilian Oregano Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Original Grandma Square - $5: Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino, Seasoned Plum Tomatoes, Fresh Garlic, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Spicy Pepperoni Square - $5.75: Slow-Cooked Tomato Sauce, Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano, Spicy Pepperoni Cups Available at: dinner, lunch
- White Sicilian Square - $5.75: Four Cheese Blend, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- Eggplant Sicilian Square - $5.75: Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino, Seasoned Plum Tomatoes, Fresh Garlic, Charred Eggplant, Basil, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
Vegan & Gluten Free
- Gluten-Free Personal Pie - $19: Customizable gluten-free crust Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Gluten-Free, Pescatarian, Low-Sodium Available at: dinner, lunch
- Vegan Pie - $24: Tomatoes, Basil, Sicilian Oregano, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Vegan Cheese Pie - $28: Tomatoes, Basil, Vio-Life Vegan Cheese, Sicilian Oregano, E.V.O.O Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Dairy-Free, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
Sides & Salads
- Garlic Knots - $4: Tied Knots, Tossed in Pecorino, Garlic, Oregano, Salt, Black Pepper, Basil, Oil with Marinara Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, GERD-Friendly, Zone, Volumetrics, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Pepperoni Wheel - $5: Crispy dough rolled with pepperoni and cheese Available at: dinner, lunch
- Cheese Calzone - $9: Ricotta and mozzarella blend Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, DASH Sodium-Reduced, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
- Chicken Roll - $9: Breaded Chicken, Sauce, Mozzarella, Pecorino and Sicilian Oregano with Marinara Dietary tags: High-Protein, Low-Sodium, High-Fiber Available at: dinner, lunch
- Caesar Salad - $8.5: Chopped Romaine Lettuce, Crunchy Croutons, Pecorino Romano, Caesar Dressing Dietary tags: Halal, Pescatarian, Anti-Inflammatory Available at: dinner, lunch
- House Salad - $9.5: Spring Mix, Black Olive, Red Onion, Cherry Tomatoes, Pecorino, Balsamic Vinaigrette Dietary tags: Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, Atkins, South-Beach, DASH Sodium-Reduced, TLC Available at: dinner, lunch
Beverages
- Bottled Water - $2.5
- Smart Water - $3.25 Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Plant-Based, Low-Sodium, Anti-Inflammatory, Atkins, South-Beach, DASH Sodium-Reduced, Low-Cholesterol, Carnivore, TLC, Alkaline, AIP, Renal, Macrobiotic, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free
- Bottled Soda - $3.25
- Gold Peak Ice Tea - $3.25 Dietary tags: Keto, Low-Carb, Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Plant-Based, Atkins, South-Beach, Carnivore, Alkaline, AIP, Macrobiotic, Slow-Carb, Lectin-Free
- Red Bull - $3.5
- Mexican Soda - $3.75 Dietary tags: Vegan, Vegetarian, Halal, Pescatarian, Heart-Healthy, Low-Sodium, Low-Fat, Low-Cholesterol, GERD-Friendly, TLC, Renal
Frequently Asked Questions about Made in New York Pizza
- Is Made in New York Pizza dairy-free-friendly?
- Yes. Made in New York Pizza has 2 dairy-free-tagged dishes on its current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie and Vegan Pie.
- What can I eat at Made in New York Pizza on a dairy-free diet?
- Vegan Cheese Pie and Vegan Pie carry the dairy-free tag, out of 2 tagged dishes on the current menu. Every dish's diet tags are listed in the menu.
- Does Made in New York Pizza have vegan options?
- Yes. 5 dishes are tagged vegan on the current menu, including Vegan Cheese Pie and Vegan Pie.
- Is Made in New York Pizza gluten-free?
- 1 dish is tagged gluten-free on the current menu. Chefi never infers allergen tags from a dish name alone, but a tag is not a certification — confirm preparation with the restaurant if you have celiac disease or a severe sensitivity.
- What is the highest-protein dish at Made in New York Pizza?
- Yo Paulie Round, at roughly 70.3g of protein (estimated from ingredients).
Restaurants near Made in New York Pizza
- Pappardella — Italian
- Uno Pizzeria & Grill — Italian
- Sempre Oggi — Italian
- Celeste — Italian
- My Pie Pizzeria Romana — Italian
- La Pecora Bianca — Italian
- Panineria — Italian
- Bellini — Italian
- Pappardella — Italian
- Salumeria Rosi — Italian
- Tarallucci e Vino — Italian
- Uno Pizzeria & Grill — Italian
